The Number 23
Rating: 2.5/5
Director: Joel Schumacher
Starring: Jim Carrey, Virginia Madsen, Danny Huston, Mark Pellegrino
Now playing: Esquire 7, Chase Park Plaza
The Astronaut Farmer
Rating: 3/5
Director: Michael Polish
Starring: Billy Bob Thornton, Virginia Madsen, Bruce Dern, Tim Blake Nelson
Now playing: Creve Coeur 12
“The Astronaut Farmer” by the Polish Brothers and “The Number 23” by Joel Schumacher opened this past weekend. Each film features Virginia Madsen (“Candyman” and “Sideways”) as the archetypal supportive wife of an obsessed man. While both films are about an obsessed man, the root of that obsession varies from virtuous to destructive.
In “The Astronaut Farmer,” Madsen plays Audie Farmer, whose husband Charles (Billy Bob Thornton) is obsessed with building a rocket in his barn and blasting into space. Nobody takes Farmer seriously, despite the fact that he is a former astronaut with advanced engineering degrees. With the launch date imminent, Charles purchases the necessary explosives, and the government suddenly sees the amateur astronaut as a threat.
This film contains some potentially debilitating qualities from the start. Number one, the plot may seem far-fetched, compounded by surreal posters depicting Thornton atop a horse in full astronaut gear. Two, it is hard to imagine the Billy Bob of Bad Santa as a sober and thoughtful family man. Three, the Polish Brothers’ past work isn’t well-known.
Despite appearances, the film is not ridiculous and Thornton gives a very believable performance. The Polish Brothers (“Twin Falls Idaho” and “Northfork”) continue to establish their strengths in cinematography and portrayals of the culture of Middle America, even if in a surreal or absurd fashion.
Indeed, “The Astronaut Farmer” is a Mid-American family film – not only in terms of its audience, but also its characters, who all depict the “family values” often discussed during election time. Despite arguments and tense moments, the Farmer family is a functional, cohesive unit that talks about important issues together at the dinner table and follows through on their responsibilities. They genuinely care for one another.
That is not to say the film is politically conservative. It uses the story as a platform to speak out on post-9/11 regulations, the tendency to mandate safety and discourage personal risk and the treatment of illegal immigrants.
Above all, the film is about pursuing dreams and supporting people who seem to have crazy ideas. The film is inspiring and a valid indictment of government-funded space exploration. As a reader of science fiction magazines Analog and Asimov’s, I’m not new to these views on the priorities and performance of NASA or the arguments against those who call for stopping manned space flights. But it is nice to see this zeal for science and discovery on screen.
On the downside, there is a quirkiness in the Polish Brothers’ older films that was missing in this one. And most of the comedy falls flat and feels over-forced. Everything is overt, from the name of Thornton’s character to dialogue stating that the government has been very effective in killing people’s dreams.
Finally, aside from Thornton, no other actor has significant time to shine in the film. Bruce Dern has some deplorably brief scenes as Audie Farmer’s father. Although short, these were some of my favorite moments. Bruce Willis, on the other hand, has some thankfully brief scenes as a military official with NASA.
Virginia Madsen does not have a complex role in “The Astronaut Farmer” or “The Number 23.” As the “supportive wife,” she only serves as a bulwark to prevent her husband from passing too far into insanity. At times her character in either movie even appears to be consciously subservient to her husband in a way not common in today’s American cinema. I expect this is done to shift each film’s focus onto fatherhood, but I can imagine some audiences might have their feathers ruffled by each of her characters.
On a different note, I have a hard time forgiving Joel Schumacher for what he (and the studio) did to Batman, but I know he can turn out some decent pictures. “The Number 23” concerns Walter Sparrow (Jim Carrey), who becomes obsessed over a mysterious novel and its numerological premise. Startled to find how closely the events of the novel follow his own life, Walter begins an unhealthy fascination with occurrences of the number 23 and sets out to find the book’s author for answers to breaking the number’s power.
The numerological plot of this story, like that of “The DaVinci Code,” is an instance of apophenia, or making connections in seemingly random events. In this case, the number 23 – or any various permutations of the number – is said to correlate with significant events.
Once you get past this bit of occult (thanks again, Dan Brown), the film is nothing more than your typical psychological thriller. There are twists and red herrings thrown in for good measure, but ultimately I don’t find the film terribly unique or memorable. No answers are given regarding the basic premise. It is clear that the number 23 does affect certain characters significantly, but for others it does nothing. We’re left to wonder still: why is this number so evil and how does it make certain people go nuts?
The answer is that it’s all a MacGuffin. All that matters here is the journey of Carrey’s character. Similar to “The Astronaut Farmer,” the film stresses the father’s strong family relationship, in this case between Walter and his son (Logan Lerman) and between Walter and his wife, Agatha. It is only this familial love and support that keeps Walter from descending into complete violence and despair. As such, “The Number 23” also firmly promotes the ideal “family values” contained in the Polish Brothers’ work.
I am a big fan of Carrey’s films outside of comedy, but there is still yet to be one that really blows me away (“Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind” came close). However, his performance in this film did make the standard thriller much more enjoyable.
“The Number 23” has a lot of buzz, while most people seem leery of “The Astronaut Farmer.” In reality, the latter is the better film, but both are worth renting one day.