Response to “The right to self-defense” - Student Life

Response to “The right to self-defense”

Being one of the few Palestinians—if not the only one—on campus, I was really disheartened to see such an academically dishonest piece as the one written by Josh Zenilman. While it is indisputable that Israel has a right to defend itself, Zenilman grossly misrepresents recent events.

Zelman’s claim that Israel disengaged from Gaza in 2005 is personally offensive. While Ariel Sharon bravely withdrew settlements from Gaza, amid considerable Israeli objection, a systematic blockade began following the democratic election of Hamas in 2006. Since then, Israel and Egypt have had direct control on flow of people and goods through Gaza, ostensibly to block shipment of arms to Hamas. This blockade has devastated the Gazan economy and has been used as a means of collective punishment. Dov Weissglass, former chief of staff, summarized: “The idea is to put the Palestinians on a diet.” Rather than joking description of the blockade, the Israeli government actually calculated the calories required to sustain Gaza and permitted less than the required amount of food to enter, necessarily requiring “illegal” smuggling tunnels. These tunnels from Egypt have accordingly become a lifeline to keep Gaza from imploding. After forcing Gazans into a catch-22, Israel maintains the right to destroy these at will, which it does frequently. Territorial sovereignty is non-existent. Gazans are routinely shot at and killed even within Gaza territory as Israel maintains a buffer region within the concrete walls surrounding Gaza. Fishermen are harassed and shot as well, limiting fishing to a polluted, small three-mile corridor, which effectively blocks finding sustenance from the sea.

Zelman insists that Israel left strong infrastructure in Gaza after the withdrawal, but whatever may have existed has fallen under disrepair without the ability to continue capital improvements. Many fundamental building materials are banned from entering Gaza in fears they can be used to build defensive bunkers. Fuel shortages require significant manual labor to rebuild and remake cement from bombed rubble—compounding the caloric dilemma. Damage from “Cast Lead,” Israel’s invasion in 2009, destroyed buildings that can never be rebuilt and razed orchards that take decades to re-grow.

So while Israeli settlers and troops have withdrawn, Gaza remains an engineered humanitarian disaster. While Israel hopes collective punishment can be used to overthrow Hamas, it has so far been unsuccessful. While Hamas certainly has been responsible for rockets historically, so have other factions in Gaza. In fact, Hamas typically enforces ceasefires remarkably well given its lack of control, even acknowledged by the IDF [Israel Defense Forces] prior to Cast Lead. The Gaza rockets are crude, within reach of an ambitious high schooler, and can be produced by anyone. They are ineffectual, pathetic grumblings of people who have no other recourse. Gazans wonder that if Israel can defend itself, how can Gaza defend itself from the blockade? Rocket and mortar launches have been as little as several per month, but the blockade still stays.

The only questions are why does Israel choose to respond so heavy-handedly? Why now? No one objects to self-defense, but not only is this collective punishment not self-defense, it doesn’t even work. The blockade has not worked in limiting launches. Cast Lead did not work in uprooting Hamas or stopping launches. Cynically, one must wonder why Cast Lead and recent events are just prior to Israeli elections. The deputy defense minister has warned Gaza of a “shoa,” Hebrew for holocaust, and Ariel Sharon’s son wrote: “We need to flatten entire neighborhoods in Gaza. Flatten all of Gaza. The Americans didn’t stop with Hiroshima—the Japanese weren’t surrendering fast enough, so they hit Nagasaki, too.” There is no shortage of hate on both sides, but without sovereignty or effective central control, Gaza is in no position to change what happens in Gaza. The key to peace is in Israeli hands.

More in op-ed Submission

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe