Letter to the editor - Student Life

Letter to the editor

On Feb. 6, an article titled “It’s OK that conservatives don’t feel welcome” was published in Student Life. In the article, the author acknowledges that conservative students feel that their ideas are unwelcome on campus—and declares this to be perfectly fine.

Their argument has two main parts. The first is that there is only a finite amount of time available for debate—making it necessary to restrict widely-discredited ideas in order to have productive discussion. The second is that conservative ideas fall into this category.

I believe that the first part of the argument is sound. Ideas that have already been thoroughly discussed in good faith and then widely discredited need not be resurrected in every discussion. It wouldn’t, for example, make sense to have a flat Earth theorist speak at a geology conference.

The second part of the argument, however, is suspect. The author gives no evidence that conservative ideas are actually limiting discussion. In fact, comparing conservative ideas to flat Earth theory (or, from the author’s example, alchemy) is misleading because conservative ideas haven’t, in general, actually been discredited. Disagreements about immigration policy, the proper role of government in providing services and whether wealth distribution ought to be carried out are entirely legitimate, and merely ignoring them (or inaccurately labeling them as sexist, nativist and quasi-democratic, as the author did) is a more realistic threat to carrying out productive discussion than those disagreements existing in the first place.

This doesn’t mean that we should trip over ourselves trying to look neutral and bipartisan. It is absolutely fine to have strong political beliefs and to express why you believe them to be true. However, if you value productive discussions, you shouldn’t declare your opposition and their ideas to be simply not welcome. That is straightforwardly non-conducive to holding any meaningful dialogue.

More in Forum

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe