News
UCLA law professor argues Supreme Court has always been political in lecture at WashU

Legal historian Stuart Banner discussed the political nature of the Supreme Court at WashU on March 25.
Stuart Banner, Norman Abrams Distinguished Professor of Law at UCLA, presented his research on the history of the politicization of the Supreme Court, March 25.
Banner’s lecture and argument centered around the fact that, despite popular opinion, today’s Supreme Court is not especially partisan compared to previous iterations of the Court. The event was part of the David T. Konig Lecture Series hosted by WashU’s Department of History.
Banner said that while many might view the contemporary court as particularly partisan compared to its past iterations, in his view, the Supreme Court has never been nonpartisan.
“People often criticize the Supreme Court today,” Banner said. “What I want to tell everyone is that [while] they often criticize the Court for deciding cases based on political grounds, … it’s always been that way. There was never a golden age of pure legal decisions.”
Banner noted that anxiety about the Supreme Court’s political leanings can increase during midterm election years, when there is potential political turnover in the legislative branch. Rumors about Justice Samuel Alito’s retirement have spiked concerns about a conservative majority.
Although there is no official confirmation of Alito’s retirement plans, Banner said that historically, justices have often planned to retire when a president from their own party is in office.
“The justices often try to time their retirement to ensure that a like-minded successor will be appointed,” he said. “The early justices tried to do the same thing — Gabriel Duvall, for example, was said to have delayed his departure from the Court for several years, despite being so deaf that he could not hear a word of oral argument, until he was assured that Roger Taney would replace him.”
Banner said that if anything is notably different in contemporary politics, it is the executive branch rather than the judiciary.
“It’s the president and the people who work for the president who are different from what they’ve been in the past,” Banner said. “The Supreme Court’s by and large doing what it’s always done. But it’s suddenly confronting all these issues that no previous administration would have yielded up: … the whole issue of birthright citizenship, … that’s something that was really never questioned until Trump.”
One audience member expressed concern about the relationship between the executive and judicial branch under the current administration due to three out of six of the current judges being Trump’s nominees and posed a question to Banner about court packing. Banner responded that he was not particularly concerned about court packing.
“For a long time, … court packing was kind of off the table … until the first Trump administration, and now suddenly it seemed to come back,” Banner said. “I don’t think that increasing the size or threatening to increase the size of the court would cause any of the current justices to change their vote. I’d be very doubtful about that, but [it] might change results.”
Banner said the main discrepancies between the Supreme Court of the past and today center around the current Court’s public campaigns, the extent of its involvement in lower court cases, and its fixed location.
“Perhaps the biggest difference between the early Supreme Court and today’s Supreme Court is that until the 19th century, the justices sat in the nation’s capital as the Supreme Court for only about two months each year,” he said. “The rest of the time they spent riding around the country from city to city, conducting trials and hearing appeals as circuit judges.”
Banner highlighted the stark contrast in diversity between today’s Court and its earlier iterations. The current Supreme Court is composed of five men and four women, including two Black justices, whereas the Court was once made up entirely of white men.
Sophomore Lauren Dukes, who attended Banner’s event, said she found his lecture inspiring.
“I feel like my main takeaway was the fact that the Supreme Court is … ever evolving,” Dukes said. “I think it’s really interesting to see the changes that have been made, how far it has come … [in terms of] diversity.”
Administrative and academic coordinator in the Department of History, Anne Morgan, said that the event attracted a wide range of attendees within and outside of WashU.
“It’s really interesting to see the diverse crowds that I brought in,” Morgan said. “Even the local community colleges came as well, which is kind of exciting.”
Dukes added that she appreciates the opportunity to hear from different experts in their fields.
“I feel like it’s important to learn from distinguished professors and people who are in different work fields,” she said. “If you want to go into that specific type of work, it’s important to hear from [experts’] own experiences and learn from them as well.”