Forum | Staff Editorials
Staff Editorial: The disturbing implications of fraternity colonization on campus
A new fraternity is colonizing at Washington University. To many, this is a statement that brings a wave of fear and anger. Even the vocabulary itself—the idea of a fraternity “colonizing” suggests overall damaging consequences. As an Editorial Board, we spent some time considering not just the foundation of our apprehension surrounding this colonization, but also the implications that the University seemingly has either not anticipated this response or has trivialized the reasons for these feelings.
Our nervousness surrounding an expansion of social fraternities is not just based on one incident, but rather a long history of social fraternities endangering and harming members of the Wash. U. community. This harm has come in many forms, including but not limited to, hazing, irresponsibility with alcohol, two guns on campus and many accounts of sexual assault.
Just last year, the Women’s Panhellenic Association (WPA) commissioned an independent survey that allowed members of social sororities to report unwanted sexual contact experienced through social fraternities. Disturbingly, the survey found instances of sexual misconduct in every single social fraternity, with the lowest reported number of instances in any one fraternity being 16, a number that can not be called low considering what it measures. These numbers were based on the responses of 848 sorority women, only 55% of sorority women. If the remaining 45% had also responded, these numbers could be even higher and there is no way that is not terrifying.
Rather than a united commitment to eradicate the problems that were brought to light through the survey, the campus saw pushback from some fraternity members. An email was sent by an anonymous fraternity member in response to the survey that showed anger towards the requests from the WPA survey that were intended to generate ideas on how to make social fraternities a safer place for women, saying that the WPA had “taken it too far” and the fraternity men “are not [WPA’s] servants”. This email spurred an activist art installation on fraternity row commenting on the results of the survey. The installation consisted of a large bar graph that represented the percentage of respondents that had experienced unwanted sexual contact at each fraternity house (the artist used a scale of one foot for each percentage point of respondents, so 14% would equal a fourteen-foot bar). The bars were then placed against the tennis courts in front of fraternity row. Sigma Alpha Epsilon (SAE), a fraternity that had a fourteen-foot bar (tied for the highest of the bars and representing 118 survivors), responded to the installation by taking their own bar down for a day before eventually returning it to its original space, suggesting some unwillingness to be held accountable. These negative reactions, paired with the fact this survey was run independently rather than by the University, speaks to how the danger posed by social fraternities needs to be taken much more seriously.
While the prospect of another social fraternity is upsetting, there were originally two different fraternities attempting to colonize on campus, Delta Chi and Sigma Alpha Mu. Only Delta Chi was approved, while Sigma Alpha Mu was not. Perhaps Delta Chi does have solid founding principles, but so does every fraternity. Phi Delta Theta’s mission statement is “to strengthen men for life by building on the tradition of our core values: friendship, sound learning and rectitude.” Just because the national organization has an honorable mission statement and core values that sound nice on paper does not mean these values will actually be upheld in practice by individual chapters, as is evident through the misconduct from all of the existing social fraternities on campus.
The Editorial Board feels that the decision to allow Delta Chi to colonize at Wash. U. shows a failure of the University to keep students’ concerns in mind while making its decisions. While executive members of the Interfraternity Council were consulted, it does not seem like the opinions of sorority members were sought after. This lack of consideration for the needs and wants of the student body was also seen through the closing of the Gargoyle, an act done without consideration of students and one that displaced many student groups such as Lunar New Year Festival, Black Anthology, Carnaval and Diwali, all cultural performance groups that the University should have supported and uses to promote its own diversity.
While creating spaces for groups to live together is good, social fraternities do not need more of this opportunity. The choice to expand social fraternities feels like the University is prioritizing the wellbeing of affluent white men rather than supporting ethnic/racial minority groups, women, gender non-conforming and non-binary individuals and low socioeconomic individuals, among other students who could use support from the University.
While many other universities are choosing to downsize or to stamp out social fraternities entirely, it feels wrong that Wash. U. has instead decided to go in the opposite direction, especially before solving the alarming issues present in all of the existing social fraternities on campus. This suggests that the University is preferring reaction rather than proactively working on the prevention of further harm, to not act until their hands are tied and there is no other option. It makes one wonder just how far things have to go before Wash. U. follows suit and downsizes its social fraternities.