Opinion Submission: It’s time to end block funding: Vote ‘yes’ on SU Amendment 1 - Student Life

Opinion Submission: It’s time to end block funding: Vote ‘yes’ on SU Amendment 1

On this week’s Student Union (SU) Election Ballot, you’ll have the choice to vote for nearly 55 candidates for 29 positions across three branches of SU – a record in recent history that our executive board is really proud of. You’ll also be asked to vote “yes” or “no” on a ballot question to approve or reject an amendment to repeal block funding. I hope you’re paying more attention to midterms than SU constitutional amendments, but I wanted to take a moment to explain what block funding is, why we are proposing changing it, and why I believe you should vote for Amendment 1. 

What is block funding? 

Block funding is written into the SU constitution and allocates a fixed, all-or-nothing amount of money during the spring budget cycle. It is supposed to give established student groups a stable, dedicated source of money. In practice, it is hard to use, unreliable, and easy to exploit. It also treats groups differently compared to funding categories, something we are trying to equalize across all student groups to protect equity and fairness. 

In the last election, my executive board ran on a core message to fix SU’s bureaucracy and make it easier to work with SU. We made 30 promises to further that mission, which you can read here. One of those promises is to get rid of block funding, which is where we need your help – to repeal a part of the constitution, we need two-thirds of voters to vote “yes” on the change. This change would be a major vote of confidence in how our board has tried to transform SU, and it is supported by three compelling reasons that promote stability, equity, and oversight. 

It is an unstable, unreliable funding source. 

Uncle Joe’s was supposed to be allocated $18,000 for phones last year. However, due to a typo (yes, a typo) in the budget, they received none of that funding from SU because block funding does not allow for any changes to its fixed amount of funding during the year. Were it not for a workaround agreement with Campus Life, Uncle Joe’s would not have the technology it needed to take calls from students who need their support because of how block funding works. That crisis was our motivation for taking on this change, but it has only been supported by more recent events. Last spring, the Emergency Support Team lost the vote to become block funded. Voters believed the proposed amount of funding was too high but also agreed that funding shouldn’t have been zero. Unfortunately, block funding is all-or-nothing. Last year’s executive board, with the approval of Treasury and Senate, was able to transfer them to an Executive Entity to secure partial funding, and this year we’ve cut their funding by almost 50% to reflect the will of the voters, but workarounds are not a permanent solution. 

Every year, block-funded groups struggle with deadlines and signature drives and then have to turn out voters again in the full election. The Sexual Assault and Rape Anonymous Hotline (S.A.R.A.H.) ran into the same problem from 2017 to 2019 before becoming an Executive Entity. Habitat for Humanity lost block funding in 2019, regained it in 2020, and ultimately chose to become a Category I group because block funding didn’t fit the nature of its events. 

When groups’ funding becomes very unreliable, their existence comes into question. Regardless of how much funding you support for a group, it is not a desirable outcome that groups can vary year to year in

receiving too much money, the right amount of money, or no money. We want to ensure consistency and put an end to finding a new workaround every year. 

It can be easily exploited, lacks oversight, and ignores the needs of the full student body. 

Because block funding depends on petitions, the process rewards whoever can mobilize signatures. It doesn’t reward whoever has the strongest case for funding. The petition records show how little the process is allowed to screen requests. In 2016, WUnderground applied for block funding to the tune of $1.4 million to buy a house. The request was passed along with a note that it was “not a joke,” and that SU would have to find a policy preventing it. In 2019, WUnderground asked for a petition link for $495,000 to buy a boat, arguing that no rule in SU’s guidelines excluded aquatic vehicles. While comical, and while if this was passed the University would likely block the expenditure, the money would be, under the block funding system, constitutionally locked into their account, meaning that the 400+ student organizations on our campus would take about a 75% budget cut. 

Whether or not you see those requests as serious, they show a system with few guardrails. Nobody could point to a policy to stop them, and the 2019 petition collected 460 signatures. On another note, when appropriated under block funding, the money is locked without oversight. There is no chance for public or SU comment on specific line items, which may be contradictory to the more consistent funding applied to the overwhelming majority of groups that take part in the category system. 

All groups should have the same rules applied to them. SU shouldn’t have more privileges than other clubs, and under the current block funding system, block funded groups have more privileges than other groups in some aspects, and in some, less than others. We should fix that. 

It is extremely difficult for student groups to use. 

To get block funding, a group must petition the student body for signatures, go through an extra round of voting, and undergo additional budget review, all before reaching the spring ballot. That’s too much bureaucracy. Once a group has the money, it has less flexibility than any other funded group. Reallocations are not allowed. Budgets and appeals are not allowed. No flat funding is given. If a block-funded group plans an event it ends up unable to host, that money sits in its line item until the end of the year, and no club can access it, meaning less money for everyone. The group can’t redirect it to another event. Entities and Category I groups don’t face these limits. We need consistency and less bureaucracy; block funded groups need flexibility, and they should also be treated like any other student group in terms of their funding. 

Vote to repeal. 

Repealing block funding would not defund anyone. Groups that currently rely on it can still seek funding as Category I groups or Executive Entities, which offer more flexibility and a more reliable path. Removing block funding from the SU constitution would put every student group on fairer, more consistent footing. 

Vote “yes.”

More in Forum

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe