In defense of Ralph Nader - Student Life

In defense of Ralph Nader

Love him or hate him, you have to respect Ralph Nader. The sheer tenacity he exhibits every four years in running for president despite getting less than one percent of the popular vote is impressive, if not particularly useful. However, this year is slightly different—with the meeting of several third party candidates to discuss key issues, it appears that the scattered hodgepodge of minority opinion is finally achieving some sort of cohesive voice.

Meeting at the National Press Club, various third party candidates sat down and discussed several key issues. The roster included Nader, Perot and perhaps the most dynamic and vitriolic of them all, Ron Paul. These unseen and unheard candidates engaged in an intense discourse that logically laid out the four key issues. The overall presentation was clean, intensive and rational. Of course, nobody actually watched it. I presume I was one of maybe a thousand viewers, tops, that actually watched the whole program. However, exponentially more viewers watched the presidential debate, and what did they get?

Thirty-second sound bites.

This isn’t for a lack of trying, either. Nader, ever the persistent fellow, actually sought to debate McCain and Obama—both summarily rejected his request. This led me to ponder the usefulness of having a third party actually debate one of the two mainstream candidates. Surely, it would add at least a little bit of legitimacy to the debates. Instead of reaching into the precompiled list of liberal v. conservative cards that would be prewritten and largely anticipated, people would actually start to think. For example, consider the common debate on how to solve the energy crisis; has anybody looked at it from an environmental standpoint? What about how this environmental standpoint affects the notion of social justice? The bipartisan bickering of our current political climate doesn’t answer the tough, legitimate questions that come from unpredictable angles. Of course, instead of having real political discourse with input from all sides, we instead have the vice presidential debate: a largely useless waste of time, money and energy. There’s no real merit to regurgitating the presidential counterparts’ points on note cards written beforehand. Statistically, the vice presidential debate doesn’t have a significant effect on voting and has only microscopic effects on the swing states in particular.

Here’s my suggestion: eschew the VPs (it’s not as if they have serious political influence post-election anyway), and force the two powerhouse political parties to face some opposition from the smaller and more diverse political candidates. Realistically, this will never happen; however, the plan brings some interesting political implications. How long has it been since we have had a real debate with real questions? How long has it been since we’ve forced the candidates to actually, god forbid, think on their feet? I’m just saying.

More in Forum

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe