Profile
Former ‘K-pop Star’ contestant moves onto freshman year
Like most students coming to campus for their first college semester, freshman Kathy Young felt fairly anonymous—but unlike her peers, she already carried a bit of fame. During her junior year in high school, Young became a renowned singer in South Korea following her performances in the inaugural season of the show “K-pop Star.”
Though she was eliminated as the field was cut from 30 to 18, her memorable time as a contestant keeps her easily recognizable for those who watched the show. Participating in this singing competition, which contains many aspects of reality television, was an experience that Young will carry forever.
The whole journey started when Young and her friends heard some Korean pop, or K-pop, music and became really interested in it. She did a lot of research and came across an audition being held by producer Park Jin-young, also known as JYP, in Toronto, nearly a five-hour drive from her hometown near Detroit. After performing at the audition, she received a callback and went on the road again for a second five-hour drive. She did not make the cut to join the label, however.
A few months later, she received a phone call asking her to audition for a new K-pop show, titled “K-pop Star,” in New York. A long talk with her mom ensued, but Young explained that she was committed and wanted to take advantage of this new opportunity.
At the auditions in New York, Young was not given a plane ticket to Korea; she was given a waiting ticket instead. Fortunately, Young got the phone call and was awarded a spot on the show. She vividly remembers being at musical rehearsal after school and answering the phone. “It felt not real, and I froze, not being able to comprehend what happened,” Young said.
When Young arrived in South Korea in November 2011, she and all the international contestants resided in the same area. She was grouped with the international participants throughout the show, which sometimes grew annoying. “We all had to travel together, so we couldn’t leave the studio until everyone was done with their practice,” Young said.
There was also a language barrier since she could only speak a few Korean phrases and understand parts of conversation. Though someone once tried—unimpressively—to show off his English skills to her, Young spoke through a translator most of the time.
Once, a fellow contestant asked Young if she liked “pee-yon-SAY.” After numerous repetitions, Young finally realized that the artist in question was Beyonce, and since the producers found this encounter particularly funny, it was featured on the show. This was one of the more embarrassing moments, she remembered.
On the show, Young had her share of ups and downs. Her first performance was “Hurt” by Christina Aguilera, and she elected to dance during her singing because she had practiced dance as a child. The judges, most notably JYP, were unimpressed. Nevertheless, she received three out of three stickers, representing the judges’ approval, and advanced to the next round.
In the later rounds of the show, the three judges, each representing a major music label in South Korea, chose contestants to join their label for the time being. Young was chosen by JYP to practice and rehearse with his company.
That was when the competition began to get stressful, Young said, “They had us work with music professionals all day. We would wake up at 8 in the morning and sometimes not get back until 4 a.m.”
At one point in the show, the contestants were put into groups based on their field; for example, all the rappers would be together. There, intragroup competition would occur, and the winners would decide with whom they wanted to work.
Young won her group and immediately knew that she wanted to work with a particular piano player. But the reality show aspects of this competition came to the forefront at this point. Young said, “The producers told me to choose two other 16-year-old girls because they wanted us to start a girl group.”
Indeed, the producers had quite an impact on the show. Before auditions, Young was often asked to submit her performance attire. One time, she was even told to wear a certain outfit to increase her sex appeal. Young thought, “I’m a 16-year-old girl. You really want me to wear less clothing for all of Korea to see?” In the end, she ended up settling for a tank top and skirt. Another time, Young was told a couple days before a show that she would be much prettier if her legs were a little skinnier.
Later on, Young was chosen again by JYP to be part of his group. At first, she was asked to do a solo, about which she felt comfortable until she learned that it was “Open Arms,” a “crazy” song sung by Mariah Carey. After the label was not satisfied with her rehearsals, it reassigned her to sing Maroon 5’s “Moves Like Jagger” in a group.
This song selection was not one of her favorites, however. Young felt that it was a relatively easy song to sing and that it did not take full advantage of her vocal skills. In addition, she was asked to dance. After taking dance classes, she remembers JYP telling her, “You’re not as bad as before, but you still should not be dancing as much.”
Her group was randomly assigned to perform in the penultimate slot, and by this time, JYP had already taken five out of his potential six to join his agency for the round. With the final group being exceptional, Young did not make the cut.
Eliminated before the round of 18, she was asked to collect all of her belongings so she could fly back home within two days. Her departure was hasty and immediate. “I had to leave while everyone else was at rehearsal, so it was disappointing that I couldn’t say goodbye,” said Young.
Young learned later that her elimination did, in fact, cause some controversy on the show. Many followers of the show thought she was better than another contestant who made it further, and it became a debated topic.
Young was asked to re-audition for the show the following year, partially to try to please her fans who thought she had been wrongly eliminated. But Young declined since she had moved on from the show and wanted to focus on her senior year and applying to college.
Though the experience is over, it has definitely impacted her life. Two of her floormates are from Korea and instantly recognized her. They were in awe and asked to take a picture with her. Now they see a lot of her, oftentimes while she is wearing sweatpants and without makeup.
Young commented that it is a little odd to be famous to some people on campus. Another friend told her that he knew people who spotted her but were too nervous to do or say anything about it.
By participating in the show, Young learned that she wasn’t interested in going back to the stressful music industry. Instead, she prefers to sing for fun and has joined the Mosaic Whispers a cappella group.
Though she has performed on television for the entire South Korean population to see, she still claims that she gets nervous singing in front of people. “I brought one of my friends to all my a cappella auditions, and you could hear me shaking through my voice.”
Young is grateful for her opportunity to be on the show but has moved on. For now, Mosaic Whispers continues to be her focus as she continues to sing. “It was cool being able to see from the other perspective on a music show like this, and it was an amazing experience.”
