Cameras installed inside houses on Upper Row - Student Life

Cameras installed inside houses on Upper Row

A camera (top center) decorates the entry hallway of the Sigma Nu fraternity’s house. Cameras were installed in houses on the Upper Row over the summer near entrances and exits.

Multiple cameras installed in each of the houses of Upper Row over the summer are the latest source of controversy in the Greek community.

The cameras, installed in the houses to monitor the exits and entryways of the University-owned residential buildings, was not a recent proposal, but rather a decision that was made five years ago in response to insurance concerns, said David Wallace, coordinator of Student Involvement and Leadership and Interfraternity Council (IFC) advisor.

But fraternity brothers say they were only informed about the changes about a week before the end of last semester and not included in discussions up to that point.

“Had they came to us before, explained it rationally, maybe let us have some input, we could have then gone to our chapters, explained why the changes were happening, how they were going to be non-invasive, and it would have been much less of a panic issue,” Joe Craig, a junior in Sigma Chi and vice president of finance for the IFC, said.

“This is a privacy concern for us; a lot of our rituals are done in our house and that’s very important that we keep those secret, obviously. Our nationals is very clear and specific about when cameras are allowed, so that’s made it even more important that we would have been involved in that conversation way in advance before they were getting installed. And from the IFC standpoint, it was just disappointing that the administration passed [on] the opportunity of what could have been a good conversation to have with us, and instead just kind of went over our heads,” Craig said.

When funding was secured to do renovations to the fraternity houses on Upper Row, it was decided that the summer would be an opportune moment to install the cameras, Wallace said.

The houses on Lower Row will have cameras installed next summer.

“It’s a big project,” Wallace said. “We broke it up into a two year process and that was a financial decision.”

The Office of Student Involvement and Leadership, not Residential Life, regulates the fraternity houses. Wallace, who is also the Coordinator for Greek Housing Programs, supervises the houses.

He stressed that while Residential Life does not directly regulate fraternity houses, the houses are still subject to the same treatment as other residential buildings.

“The chapter halls are different than residential halls, but the safety and security of our students is paramount,” Wallace said. “And infrastructure-wise, they’re still university-owned buildings.”

Wallace noted that all the other residential buildings on campus have security cameras at the entrances and exits, and to not do the same for fraternity house would constitute preferential treatment.

“We shouldn’t be treating one segment of the population any differently than another,” he said.

Senior Eric Fischer, IFC president and member of Kappa Sigma, said that the fraternity presidents learned in a meeting at the end of April that the cameras would be installed.

Fischer said that the decision came as less of a shock to the IFC after some incidents last year in which fraternity members living in the houses reported their belongings had gone missing, but still as something of a surprise.

“Every time that came up, it would be mentioned that if that was a problem, cameras might come,” Fischer said. “But it never really seemed all that definite…not that close to being enacted.”

The rest of the brothers were notified after the decision was made.

Wallace said that in discussions regarding the decision there was no mention of specific incidents that inspired the installment of the cameras.

According to Wallace, the cameras are intended solely for follow-up investigation by WUPD on the occasion that a serious incident takes place in a fraternity house, and they will not be constantly monitored.

“They’re not [there] to bust parties—they are for serious incidents and the follow-up,” he said.

Fischer did not anticipate the cameras would be well received by members of the fraternities.

Jeff Shevach, a senior in Sigma Alpha Epsilon, expressed confusion and concern over the new cameras.

“It’s sort of been more confusion than anything else, because, from the safety perspective, they don’t really change anything,” Shevach said. “The only way they would help out is if someone swipes in if someone stole someone’s card or something… [or] I guess if one of the staff members commits a crime within three feet of the door or something.”

Shevach also noted the limited range of the cameras, which were only placed at the doors.

“At least from our perspective, there’s no real way this enhances our safety,” he said.

Some fraternity members voiced apprehension over the fact that the cameras were placed inside the houses, in partial view of common spaces.

“They did a good job positioning the cameras so they would show as little of the house as possible and mainly focus on the doors, but brothers still walk around there at night, if they need to go grab something from somewhere in the house. There’s the potential that they could still get caught on one of those cameras, and that’s worrisome just because that’s obviously an invasion of their privacy,” Craig said.

While the cameras may be met with a negative response, Fischer pointed out that ultimately the decision was out of the hands of the fraternity community.

“I know that several presidents have complained, but it’s the school’s decision and we don’t really have much say in it,” he said.

Craig hopes that some of the larger concerns about the cameras will prompt a conversation between Greek students and administrators.

“This kind of shows there is a small disconnect between the administration and Greek Life, but I think it’s also a good opportunity for us to start that line of communication, to communicate what we want as Greek men and women and what they want of us,” Craig said. “ Although it was not a good thing that happened, I think it pointed out a pretty big flaw that I think now we can address moving forward.”

With additional reporting by Sadie Smeck and Michael Tabb

More in Campus Events

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe