Forum | Staff Editorials
Staff Editorial: The University must support its students

Chancellor Martin speaks at the Day of Dialogue & Action in 2019. Photo by Grace Bruton | Student Life
Time moves fast on a college campus, but the past four days have exhausted even the sturdiest of the Washington University community. Mentally and emotionally, Saturday’s events and the chaos in the days following has taken a toll on all of us. Instead of supporting its community through this stressful period, however, the University has failed its student body by consistently choosing ignorance, silence and hypocrisy. At a time when students need proactive support from leadership more than ever, they have been left to fend for themselves.
Starting with Chancellor Andrew Martin’s statement, emailed to the community on Sunday night, the University failed to uphold the values of its institution and support its students. Nearly 36 hours following the events, long after the campus conversation had moved past the right or wrong of Fadel Alkilani’s actions, Martin failed to even acknowledge much less denounce — the blatant racism, bigotry and Islamophobia being directed at members of the community, particularly Black, brown and Muslim students. Thirty-six hours is more than enough time to recognize the issue (nearly everyone on campus already had); his silence indicates either a shocking ignorance about the state of his own university or an even more concerning willingness to allow this hateful rhetoric to continue.
In place of a single line addressing this issue, he praised the value of free speech — its importance within the community, its ability to empower. In the same breath, Martin denounced Alkilani’s protest, an act which is inherently an expression of speech. More importantly, we recognize that no act of speech on campus should be met with the appalling response experienced by Alkilani and the Black, brown and Muslim members of our community. Yet, in his assertion that Alkilani will face “the consequences of his actions,” the Chancellor implied that hate speech, doxxing and death threats are justified responses to events of this nature. A member of the community received threats on his life, and the response was tacit acceptance. In what it contained and what it lacked, his statement signaled to the WashU community a confused application of our right to free speech as well as a strong disregard for our safety on campus.
Four days after Martin’s statement, the University has not uniformly condemned — and the Chancellor has yet to acknowledge — the Islamophobia and hateful rhetoric existing on our own campus. Fears have justifiably grown out of this unchecked vitriol to the point that many students felt unsafe stepping onto their own campus on Wednesday. Countless students expressed their worries, anxieties and fears, and the University ignored their concerns. At a moment when a proactive response by the University could have allayed these fears, we were met with a stunning silence.
The Washington University Police Department’s call for normalcy in a Tuesday night email, asserting that there is no “credible threat to the university,” ignores the larger issue surrounding the University’s response. Whether or not there was a genuine threat to campus security the following day, is a credible threat the benchmark for taking action to support students? Must we wait until we are in immediate danger for the University to do something? Furthermore, this narrative discounts the immense mental and emotional stress that the Islamophobia and hate speech put on students. Mental health is as important as physical health; to call for normalcy in a time when distress is painfully obvious is to devalue the voice and feeling of the student body.
In an email to faculty and staff sent Tuesday night that has since circulated on social media, the Dean of the Faculty of Arts and Sciences expressed that, since there is, again, “no credible threat,” professors had no obligation to accommodate students who participated in Wednesday’s strike or simply felt unsafe coming to class. The University chose to meet the fears of its students with the possibility of unexcused absences. Furthermore, in their statement to students, they expressed how “it is inspiring to see so many students and faculty on campus, continuing the precious work of learning and discovery.” Their ascribal of courage to those who attended class on Wednesday makes an implicit and disparaging comment on those who, for one reason or another, choose not to. Whether or not a credible threat loomed on campus, the anxiety it caused should have been grounds for concern. Luckily, many professors were more considerate and listened to their students when they expressed their anxieties.
As students, none of us should feel unsafe on the grounds of WashU. If campus is meant to be a space for expressing opinions and fostering a positive, safe environment, the University must be responsive and supportive when its students are in crisis. Ignoring issues and disparaging those who are affected goes against the values that WashU stands for. Multiple statements have expressed that the University is “here for you,” but actions speak louder than words. Simply put, the University must support its students.