Scene
‘Behemoth!’ and ‘Elsinore’ confront mortality and artistic legacy, but quite differently

Luke Passwater | Staff Illustrator
When death begins to loom large over your life, how do you find a purpose and ensure that you leave a legacy? This is the central question posed by two new films that had early screenings at this year’s annual St. Louis International Film Festival: Tony Gilroy’s “Behemoth!” and Simon Stone’s “Elsinore”. These films, both shown at the Hi-Pointe Theatre on Nov. 6 and 7, were some of the first films screened as a part of the film festival, and both screenings were packed full.
“Behemoth!”, starring the beloved Pedro Pascal, is a drama about Alex Serian, a talented cellist who returns to his hometown of Los Angeles to care for his dying mother, and in the process must confront past traumas that he had been avoiding. Written and directed by Tony Gilroy, who most recently was the showrunner of the Star Wars show “Andor,” “Behemoth!” is an undeniably ambitious film, utilizing a non-linear narrative reminiscent of a Christopher Nolan film. The film features nine different prominent musical composers, billed together as “The Behemoth! Collective,” each composing music for a scene in the film befitting their own unique style.
Despite the suspension of disbelief required to fully enjoy the more theatrical plot points of this film, “Behemoth!” is uplifted by superb acting, excellent cinematography, and a creative combination of film score and storytelling. Pascal brings his usual charm and talent to the film, as well as a sense that there is something simmering just beneath the surface of Alex’s calm demeanor.
His acting is complemented by the cinematography of Damián García, who previously worked on “Andor” with Gilroy, which dazzles us with shots of bright symphony halls, snowy back alleys, quiet Los Angeles streets, and colorful light reflections off of car hoods. Nonetheless, the highlight of the film is its method of non-linear storytelling, which leads us from present to past to the more recent past and back again, all the while accompanied by a dramatic orchestral score that is intentionally trope-like in its use, a kind of meta wink at the audience. These elements combined create a film that, while not revolutionary, is certainly noteworthy, and definitely an entertaining and worthwhile way to spend two hours.
The same can be said about “Elsinore”, an emotional film starring Andrew Scott based on the true story of Scottish actor Ian Charleson’s performance of “Hamlet” at London’s National Theatre while suffering from AIDS. Directed by Simon Stone, the film plays out like any other biographical drama, but is set apart by Andrew Scott’s sublime performance and an emotional weight that is carried throughout the film.
While “Elsinore” is certainly a heavy film, it is also quite funny and joyous. “Elsinore” tries to impress on us the value of living life to its fullest and is peppered with comedic bits that lighten the emotional load. In one particularly delightful scene, some younger patients at an AIDS clinic perform a rendition of “There’s No Business Like Show Business” for a group of older patients, exemplifying the tagline of the film: “Live. Gloriously.” Andrew Scott’s portrayal of Ian Charleson is the highlight: He expertly balances the lighter moments with outbursts of anguish befitting a man faced with his own mortality. “Elsinore” is simultaneously heartbreaking and inspirational, telling a story that rightfully deserves a place on the silver screen.
Warning: Spoilers Ahead!
Despite their differences, “Behemoth!” and “Elsinore” also share a lot of similarities: Both films feature outstanding performances from strong leading actors playing talented artists, and both main characters face a life crisis that forces them to reevaluate their purpose and legacy. These life crises are both brought on by the presence of death, which manifests in different ways between the two films, leading the two characters to approach their purpose and legacy differently.
In “Behemoth!” Alex Serian decides to forgo any important legacy and instead finds purpose in mentoring the next generation of musicians before fading into relative obscurity. Alex’s life has been riddled with trauma, from being groomed at a young age, surviving a car crash, coping with the death of his father and a former lover, to his mother’s death which begins his current crisis.
Despite his successful career Alex struggles to find any fulfillment in a world that only continues to hurt him. He eventually finds a little purpose in befriending and mentoring one of the younger cellists that he works with, guiding them through the audition process for a prestigious symphony orchestra. Furthermore he tracks down his own biological daughter, a musical prodigy herself, and workshops an original composition with her. Upon finishing the session with his daughter, Alex comes to a revelation: His own legacy is unnecessary and his purpose is already fulfilled because the next generation is doing just fine without him. In a dramatic ending Alex moves to Europe to live a simpler life, leaving the audience with the almost uneasy idea that purpose and legacy can be abandoned.
“Elsinore” on the other hand leaves us with a much different message: leave a great legacy and find a great purpose, even in the face of death. Ian Charleson’s life is falling apart and coming to an end; close friends of his are dying and his own life is threatened by AIDS. Despite this, he wants one last triumphal hurrah; to live life as he puts it: “Gloriously.” Against his doctor’s wishes, Ian goes out swinging, playing Hamlet on stage in his final role and leaving the legacy of a great artist. This ending is certainly much more inspiring than that of “Behemoth!”, but also easier to swallow; there’s something commendable about Gilroy’s film’s willingness to challenge the audience with its conclusion.
Death and life crises are challenging things to navigate, not least of all when life’s purpose and legacy are on the line. Even if they reached different conclusions, both films did a stellar job at tackling these themes.
“Behemoth!” and “Elsinore” both release in theaters nationwide on December 4, 2026.