Forum
Dance dance (no) revolution
Nobody wants to dance anymore. I’ve seen it myself, and I’m sure anyone who’s gone out recently has, too. This isn’t just anecdotal; evidence of this phenomenon has been circulating on the internet for a while now. Which is a bit confusing, as humans are hardwired to like dancing. The bottom line: It’s the phones.
We carry cameras on us constantly, and subsequently feel compelled to record anything and everything, and to distribute these recordings as content. iPhones have made everyday citizens a critical component of the surveillance state. We have become Flock cameras with access to private spaces, such as the club. You can no longer get sloppy drunk without evidence of this possibly making its way to social media.
It’s one thing to get laughed at for dancing weird in the moment. It’s another to have that weird dance go viral on TikTok for millions to see. The kind of fear social media is instilling in individuals might help explain Gen Z’s acceptance of puritanical ideas.
The pandemic accelerated the existing decline of third spaces, and everyone has become more lonely. Social distancing really did a number on social spaces. Bars and clubs were hit especially hard. The pandemic made us scared to go out and threw vulnerable populations into a constant state of fear. Just ask the COVID-conscious lesbian bar in Massachusetts.
Gen Z is consuming way less alcohol than previous generations. Rising costs have made people, especially Gen Zers, unable or unwilling to spend money at the club, especially when their morning coffee is $8. Not only is Gen Z scared to dance, but we’re financially restricted from entering the spaces where it’s supposed to be encouraged.
Gen Z is consuming less alcohol than previous generations did in their youth, and recent reports have suggested that Gen Z is spending the same proportion of their income on alcohol as everyone else. This alcoholic aversion might not be a generational personality quirk, but an unfortunate financial consequence contributing to Gen Z’s push towards morally righteous beliefs.
With bars and clubs shutting down, young people have begun to pursue different avenues to blow off steam. ‘Soft clubbing’ has become one of their vices. Instead of late-night bar crawls, we’ve seen increased attendance for coffee clubbing events, wellness raves, and thermal gatherings. Young people appear to crave controlled environments, an unfortunate consequence of the constant scrutiny of our generation’s behaviors.
While the sweating and elevated heartbeat persist on the occasional night out, the act of dancing itself has fallen by the wayside. Soft clubbing seems to be more about wellness than anything else, with people gathering in droves to work out, chug non-alcoholic liquids, and go on runs before doing any dancing.
The real issue underlying all of this is the surveillance state and our inability (and maybe unwillingness) to escape our participation in it. Bars and clubs shutting down isn’t a new phenomenon. That has been happening since the turn of the century. Nowadays, social media and smartphones are outgrowing their infancy and establishing themselves as an essential component of the human condition. This integration brewed a concoction of watchfulness and fear that is particularly poisonous to the act of dancing.
What can we do if we wish to dance away from the prying eyes of the newest iPhones? Certain clubs across Europe and the United States are requiring patrons to cover their phone cameras with stickers before entering. This way, people are free to dance as they like without fear of being recorded.
But a practice that requires self-control might not be the best approach. So some artists are requiring their fans to deposit their phones into locked bags before entering a venue. In doing so, people are forced to live in the moment: You can rip a sticker off, but it’s a lot harder to break a lock.
If we implemented either of these practices, and made leisure more affordable, we could (hopefully) stop the decline of dancing, but the change doesn’t require authoritarian interference.
Put that phone down and dance!