Odd one out: Perspective in summer reading discussions - Student Life

Odd one out: Perspective in summer reading discussions

We have all been told at least once, whether it was by our mom or some old lady at the grocery store with a singsong Southern accent, that we will find our place in college, and that everyone’s just as uncomfortable or frightened or confused as the rest. I beg to differ.

How can I take this “universal truth” to heart when I know it’s not true for me? As a black student, I can’t be told that this feeling of otherness is fleeting and in my head when it is consistently compounded by visual evidence: Almost every time I enter a room on campus, I realize I am the only one who doesn’t really look like anyone else.

This year in particular, black freshmen face a unique predicament. For the incoming class of 2020, the First Year Reading Program Steering Committee chose “Between the World and Me” by renowned author Ta-Nehisi Coates as required summer reading. The widely acclaimed book reads as a letter from Coates to his son on what it means to be black in America. He delves into the ramifications of slavery and labels its perpetuations, such as the fatal shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo., which occurred only minutes from Washington University’s campus. Coates also touches on the lesser-known, more horrific foundations of the American Dream, which he claims are rooted in the “destruction of black bodies,” and forces readers to reassess how they view both the country and themselves. While I appreciate Wash. U.’s efforts to shine a light on the topic, I wish that light did not also call to center stage the difference in identity some freshmen may wish to set aside at the beginning of the year.

In late July, freshmen received a special Wash. U. edition of “Between the World and Me.” The cover included a quote by Toni Morrison: “This is required reading.” I agree that this riveting work of art deserves to be the book that students are forced to read and analyze. It’s great that students have this exposure to the challenging reality of a large portion of the American population. However, choosing this as freshmen required reading only exaggerates the aforementioned outsider sensation that black students often face. As we sit in our small discussion groups and talk about the book, it calls even more attention to the separation of a black student who may already feel like the odd one out.

Many members of the incoming class attended SOAR. At the end of program, the student leaders asked us about “Our Washington.” Essentially, we were to write one word describing what we hoped Wash. U. would be for us. While most wrote “home” and some wrote “fun,” I wrote “freeing.” Despite Wash. U.’s dreadfully low diversity percentages, I had hoped to escape the uncomfortable feeling of being looked to to speak for an entire people. Now that I know my first interaction with my classmates will be a discussion, maybe debate, about what it’s like to be me, or my brother, or my cousin that hope is already fading.

As these book discussions come upon us, I urge all students to approach these topics with sensitivity, respect and perspective. Keep in mind that these topics may hit closer to home for some students. Of course, mistakes will be made. We may slip up and say something we really didn’t mean or make a comment with an unintended connotation, and that’s okay. We are all here to learn from each other. Let’s just make sure that these lessons are not at the expense of our classmates.

More in Freshman Press

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe