Scene
The sweet battle: Insomnia Cookies vs. Dough to Door
Fewer than five months after Dough to Door moved east to its new location on the Delmar Loop, Insomnia Cookies became another Loop dweller. Both establishments make their cookies in small batches and serve them fresh. If you are a cookie lover like me and many other Washington University students, prepare yourself for the ultimate cookie showdown.
An assortment of Insomnia Cookies.
Location
Dough to Door’s relocation between Pi Pizzeria and the Delmar MetroLink Station may result in a decrease in student customers due to the location’s distance from the Danforth campus. Still, its greater visibility on the Loop could open up a larger market for the growing business. Insomnia Cookies, however, is conveniently located between Subterranean Books and Peacock Diner, which neighbor the Lofts of Washington University.
Winner: Insomnia Cookies
Ambience
Walking into Insomnia Cookies, the first thing I saw was a large freezer full of eight barrels of ice cream. The decor is simple and modern-looking—you wouldn’t know it was a cookie shop if it weren’t for the huge cookie logo on the window. Unlike Dough to Door, which displays its freshly baked cookies on the counter, Insomnia Cookies only has a plate of plastic-wrapped samples on the table beside the register. Ironically, the minimal display of cookies and uniformed dark aprons worn by workers makes Insomnia Cookies look much cleaner.
Winner: Insomnia Cookies
Flavor
As most of you are probably already familiar with Dough to Door’s cookie selections, let’s just say that Insomnia Cookie has the edge: it has reinvented the traditional idea of a cookie shop. You can order a la mode, which has two scoops of ice cream to go along with your cookie of choice, or upgrade to an ice cream sandwich to your liking. A S’mores Deluxe cookie with cake pop ice cream just sounds so…rich. Also, good news for peanut butter fans—Insomnia Cookies offers toppings like peanut butter chips, Snickers and Reese’s Cups to add some extra flavor to your cookie. I got the classic Chocolate Chunk cookie, and it’s the perfect combination of a crispy-chewy exterior and a creamy half-melted chocolate filling. Health-wise, each Insomnia chocolate chunk cookie contains 230 calories while its fellows at Subway, which are surprisingly greasier, are only 210 calories each. But who cares? A cookie is a cookie.
Winner: Insomnia Cookies
Delivery
The large kitchen at Dough to Door’s new location enables the store to deliver an order within 30 minutes instead of an hour. Insomnia Cookies has two cars parked right outside of its store for delivery, each with a cute logo box on the roof. Although an employee said delivery to campus would take around 15 minutes, an online ordering page advertised the wait time as up to 45 minutes.
Winner: Dough to Door

Intangibles
If you like the Happy Hour cookies, stick with Dough to Door. Insomnia Cookies does not currently accept Bear Bucks, but you can use them for in-store orders at Dough to Door.
Winner: Dough to Door
Final Score:
Dough to Door — 2
Insomnia Cookies — 3
The restaurants’ names explain their market positions. Dough to Door is a better choice for delivery while Insomnia Cookies better satisfies late-night dessert cravings with its extended selection.
WINNER: INSOMNIA COOKIES … and that’s the way the cookie crumbles!
