Staff Columnists
Blowback: A lesson in American exceptionalism
Barack Obama ran for president on the promise of returning American soldiers from Iraq and carefully disengaging with the Middle East over his time in office. After a recent address to the nation, it is apparent that he seems to be holding onto the premise by a thread, outlining a counter-terrorism program that could be interpreted as war without the title.
Airstrikes will be the offensive of choice once again for the Obama administration, whose pledge is to “hunt down terrorists who threaten our country, wherever they are.” Obama later paralleled this effort to several other “successful” engagements with terrorists in Yemen and Somalia. It is important to note that the Yemen and Somalia ordeal has lasted for over 13 years now to little resolve. This detail should have us all questioning how long the Obama administration truly foresees this Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant conflict continuing.
By administering a two-year plan, we can see that there is an expectation of continued action most likely beyond these two years, but Obama will have escaped from office by then. Don’t be fooled by the two-year facade—this could easily slip into another decade of Middle Eastern war-like involvement, judging by the rhetoric.
Do we know we are falling into a trap? Do we have some alternate, possibly profitable, scheme of which I am unaware? Or are we simply backed too far into this corner of exceptionalism that demands we continue our pursuit to police the world?
Americans should be debating the concept of airstrikes as a response to extremism. You can’t kill ideas with airstrikes, but you can strengthen them. And this is precisely what ISIL seems to understand, and that we have missed the logic of entirely. ISIL has invited us to Iraq and Syria because they know it will lead to further support for their anti-American cause. It is also known that ISIL, continuing the work of Al-Qaeda, is attempting to further bankrupt us in an endless, expensive engagement.
Currently, we spend $7.5 million daily on airstrikes, and the upward mobility of this number is unknown. Let’s remember that our current tab for the War on Terror over the last decade is roughly $6 trillion, according to a 2013 report by the Harvard Kennedy School of Government. I understand that these numbers can be lost in interpretation, but that’s over $50,000 per United States household. At the onset, a top economic adviser in the Bush administration estimated that the Iraq War would cost between $100 billion and $200 billion. It is said that history doesn’t repeat itself, but it does rhyme, and it’s critical that we recognize the economic trap that a conflict with ISIL presents.
But how should we respond to ISIL? After all, the terrorist organization has been outwardly arrogant in its beheading of two innocent Americans. I can’t express my detestation of ISIL enough—it is the most dangerous group that we have ever come up against.
Yet it seems as though we should pick up on at least one lesson from the last decade, even if it has cost us $6 trillion to learn: that engagement with ISIL is a lose-lose.
Chelsea Manning wrote an article recently entitled, “How to make ISIS fall on its own sword,” in which she outlined an approach that deserves attention, keeping in mind that she was formerly an “all-source analyst” in Iraq around the time ISIL began to take form. Manning makes the point that “The Islamic State’s center of gravity is, in many ways, the United States, the United Kingdom and those aligned with them in the region.”
Her solution is one of containment and patience that would allow for ISIL to keep its form in a confined area long enough to lose its popularity and separate internally, eventually failing in its caliphate. I understand this is a difficult approach to accept on the heels of several dead Americans and an array of threats to our nation, but at what point will America stop playing checkers while ISIL and other extremist groups play chess?