Freshman Press
‘Go Set a Watchman’ hints at path not taken
“Go Set a Watchman” hit the shelves in a whirlwind of controversy this summer. Many critics claim that Harper Lee, an 89-year-old stroke victim living in a nursing home, is not of sound-enough mind to authorize her book’s publishing. Her sister and longtime caretaker, Alice, passed away last November, conveniently leaving the previously unpublished manuscript in the hands of Tonja Carter, Lee’s self-proclaimed “estate trustee, lawyer and friend.” Carter claims to have first found the manuscript shortly before Alice died, but she was present at a Sotheby’s meeting in 2011 planned to discuss the contents of Lee’s safety deposit, when the draft of “Go Set a Watchman” was discovered.
Carter then passed the manuscript onto billion-dollar publishing firm HarperCollins. Joe Nocera, a writer for the New York Times, calls the novel an “epic money grab,” as HarperCollins refers to the release as the “fastest-selling book in company history.”
Lee has consistently asserted that she wanted to write a “race novel.” “Go Set a Watchman” was written before “To Kill a Mockingbird,” although it was set after the landmark novel. Because readers, prompted by HarperCollins, refer to the book as a “sequel,” they are shocked by Atticus Finch’s newfound racism. Since Atticus Finch is a fictional character, no one should regard this drastic change as a major character flaw. Instead, “Go Set a Watchman” should be seen as a completely new novel, with the same character names and setting as “To Kill a Mockingbird.”
In fact, it’s almost written as one. Jem’s death (don’t panic, it’s on the second page), for example, is not introduced with the same weight readers would expect for one of “To Kill a Mockingbird’s” primary characters.
“Go Set a Watchman” began as Lee’s great race novel, which she then changed into a (subjectively) “better” one: “To Kill a Mockingbird.” Readers need not harp on the racist undertones of the newest book. Take “To Kill a Mockingbird” as Harper Lee’s “race novel” and “Go Set a Watchman” as the “gender novel.” It focuses on Scout’s—ahem, Jean Louise’s—issues as a transitioning tomboy, as she pressures herself into marrying a childhood friend and debates the aspects of her life as a city woman that contradict her womanly duties. The second women’s movement had not yet occurred, leaving her adrift in a world of extreme femininity and the pressures of Southern grace.
If Lee had continued with this as the central idea, this novel could’ve emerged as the great “gender novel.” But, for now, readers must distance themselves from the progressive hero they once knew and focus on the evolving one before them.