News
‘I want to fight for justice’: Sotomayor attendees take inspiration from her talk

More than 3,000 people attended Justice Sotomayor’s talk in the Athletic Complex on Sept. 10. (Bri Nitsberg | Managing Photo Editor)
Justice Sonia Sotomayor spoke to a packed crowd of over 3,000 community members, students, teachers, and alumni in the Athletic Complex last Wednesday, Sept. 10. She entered and left to a standing ovation and frequently had to pause for thunderous applause. The first words from moderator Chancellor Martin were that the event had “sold out in 52 minutes.”
Sotomayor spoke at WashU as part of her “Just Shine!: How to Be a Better You” book tour. Drawing on the life of her mother Celina and her unique “ability to make everyone around her shine,” Sotomayor’s book promotes a message of love, understanding, and forgiveness, which many audience members found particularly salient during a time of great political volatility, polarization, and dissatisfaction.
Noura Habona, a junior studying Global Studies, was excited by Sotomayor’s message.
“I felt like everything she had to say was very touching,” Habona said. “She has a lot of wisdom. I liked hearing her touching on … the space in the world that she’s in right now.”
However, some attendees — including junior Noor Huda — felt Sotomayor was overly optimistic. Huda said she’s “been feeling very uneasy and I think that a lot of people feel that way as well.”
Huda, an aspiring lawyer majoring in Political Science, said she agreed with parts of Sotomayor’s message, but not all of it.
The parts about “being open and being empathetic” resonated with her, as it “is one of the most important ways to go about a constructive political dialogue,” Huda said.
“But I feel like a lot of people in this country are being vilified, and are not being given that same forgiveness that Justice Sotomayor was speaking about.”
Sotomayor acknowledged similar concerns during the Q&A section of the talk. When asked about how she stays hopeful for the future, Sotomayor first looked to the past. She drew a parallel between activism occurring today to that of the Civil Rights Movement, notably, the Dred Scott decision of 1857.
The landmark Supreme Court case ruled that any Black American whose ancestors were brought to this country and sold as slaves were not citizens within the meaning of the Constitution of the United States and declared the Missouri Compromise to be unconstitutional.
“Many cases were lost in those 100 years, and many cases are being lost right now, but we don’t have a right to give up. We don’t have a right to sit on our hands and say it’s OK,” Sotomayor said. “We have an obligation to pick up that mantle and continue to fight.”
Habona said that Sotomayor’s call to action resonated with her on a personal level.
“She inspires not just people of color, but women of color and just people who grew up in disadvantaged backgrounds,” Habona said. “She really shows how you can change your narrative, and you can be an example for so many others in your position.”
In addition to a message of tenacity, Sotomayor shared personal stories from her life, highlighting her childhood and relationship to her family.
Sotomayor spoke extensively about her connection to her mother, Celina Báez, whom she called her “example of never giving up, of trying to do the right thing, and of always, always helping others.”
As a nurse, Báez worked tirelessly to help those in need.
“She tended to everyone,” Sotomayor recalled. “Not only her patients at the hospital, but her friends and neighbors, too. A boy who had broken an arm or a girl who had a stomach ache, a toddler with a fever, or a grandfather with back pain.”
Sotomayor also touched on the darker parts of her upbringing. She spoke candidly about her father’s alcoholism and how it fueled her mother’s absence. That, paired with her mother’s effectively nonexistent relationship with her own parents, made Sotomayor’s childhood lacking in affection.
“I asked [her] why didn’t you hug me when I was a kid?” Sotomayor said. “She said, ‘Sonia, no one hugged me when I was a kid. How was I supposed to know how to hug you?’”
Sotomayor said the conversations with her mother helped her to understand the importance of forgiveness and healthy communication.
“Those moments of truth had happened because we had both grown up enough to have that conversation without defensiveness or anger,” Sotomayor said.
A diverse group of audience members were present at the event, including faculty members, students, teachers, alumni, and members of the larger St. Louis community. Sotomayor’s words of hope for the future seemed to resonate with many of those present. Shonda Ayers, a local public school teacher, was excited to share Sotomayor’s words with her class.
“I’m gonna take back to my students ‘You can do anything you set your mind to,’” Ayers said. “And to look to your parents, because they are your main example.”
Sotomayor had advice for the many children in the audience.
“The world is so much bigger than you know,” said Sotomayor in response to a question from two sisters in elementary school. “I would say to you to spend your time reading outside of school about what other people are doing.”
Several of the kids in the audience also had takeaways. Aubrey Gillenwater, a St. Louis elementary school student, said she was excited to read Justice Sotomayor’s book.
“I want to fight for justice,” Gillenwater said.