In defense of ‘Teen Mom’ - Student Life

In defense of ‘Teen Mom’

The MTV television lineup is essentially a slew of vehicles for the self-indulgent and unemployed (How is “Real World/Road Rules Challenge” still a thing?) Amid the fist-pumps and alcoholism and desperate greed so glorified by the network, however, we have “Teen Mom.”

A spinoff of “16 and Pregnant,” “Teen Mom” follows the struggles of four young girls in their day-to-day lives after giving birth. The show could easily be exploitative: These girls clearly aren’t mature enough to make the best decisions, and most don’t have a stable family support network to help them do so. And the bizarre scrapbook theme of the credits and transitions almost seems to make light of their real problems with cutesy graphics of rattles and rubber ducks surrounding still photos memorializing arguments, tears and heartache.

Somehow, though, “Teen Mom” manages to be one of the most honest and riveting television shows I’ve ever seen. Seriously. Besides the fact that it’s probably the most convincing public service announcement for safe sex ever made, watching these girls confront the harsh realities of their lives and grow up—sort of—onscreen is fascinating. Take Farrah, whose immaturity makes her slightly incompetent as a mother: Baby Sophia is usually left sitting on countertops, if Farrah can even remember where she left her. Still, Farrah goes to culinary school, waitresses, takes care of her daughter, tries to mend her relationship with her abusive mother and deals with the grief of losing Sophia’s father in a car accident. This is no “My Super Sweet 16.”

Amber seems to be the most falsely dramatic, in the traditional “reality show” way: She’s whiny, abusive and selfish, constantly breaking up and getting re-engaged to hapless Gary. This show, however, doesn’t allow for any falsity, so she just comes off as a pathetic and dangerous teenager, trapped in a squalid apartment without even a high school degree to her name.

The most endearing story is that of Catelynn and Tyler, the only couple who decided, heart-wrenchingly, to give their baby up for adoption. They made the right choice in not wanting to bring a baby into their unstable lives, but their parents—her mother is married to his father, making them step-siblings, more “reality show” gold that is all but ignored here—still harbor bitter resentment for that choice. Catelynn and Tyler legitimately look like they’re 12 years old; they had unprotected sex almost immediately after Catelynn gave birth, and they say things like “I just frickin’ love you.” But they are also unbelievably mature, especially in the face of their home lives. In the season finale, they visited their daughter and her adoptive parents, and instead of emotionally breaking down and doubting their decision, they simply took joy in the fact that they made the right decision in giving her up—making it one of the more poignant scenes I’ve seen on television in quite some time and adding some much-needed hope and optimism to these stories.

“Teen Mom” is what all reality TV should be: actual reality, with all of its ups and downs. Watching it is an emotional experience that’s not fun but definitely affecting and addicting. Interested? A new season of “16 and Pregnant” premieres Tuesday on MTV at 10 p.m./9 p.m. Central.

More in TV

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe