You change all the lead in my head: 10 years of Arcade Fire’s “Funeral” - Student Life

You change all the lead in my head: 10 years of Arcade Fire’s “Funeral”

It begins in a bedroom, as dreams of escaping fill our young narrator’s head. Escape from the sobs of his parents. Escape from his neighborhood, buried in snow. Escape to the love of his life, who turns the lead in his head to gold. They do escape, starting anew and soon forget their past lives. We’re never given details, aside from hair grown long and memories lost, but we don’t need them, because Arcade Fire deals in a brand of intimacy that’s universal.

On its stunning debut album, “Funeral,” which celebrated its 10th anniversary last Sunday, Arcade Fire spun the pain of loss (the album’s name was inspired by the pervasive familial deaths that occurred while recording it) into its childhood hopes and dreams, creating something that’s both deeply personal and widely relatable. While it initially presents itself with all the bombast of a musty diary, “Funeral”’s ability to stir up lost loves and discarded dreams—all while conjuring the beauty that makes that disappointment tolerable—turned it into an unlikely success, propelling Arcade Fire to Grammy’s upsets and Super Bowl commercials.

But perhaps “Funeral”’s success wasn’t so unlikely. Though Arcade Fire has mined its gifts for anthemic propulsion to profoundly satisfying effect in the years since “Funeral”’s release, the band has never sounded so intimate since. Unlike some of its followers, Arcade Fire understood that the only path to transcendence begins from within. A “woah ohhh” is only worth the thought behind it, and Arcade Fire plucked every orchestral swell and impassioned shout from the depths of its soul. It’s the stakes that make “Funeral” so darned moving, as if the fate of mankind rested on these 10 songs.

The problem is, these kinds of lofty ambitions often lead to pretension. A desire to reckon with God can turn into a god complex faster than Bono belting a string of “yeah yeah yeah yeahs,” but “Funeral”-era Arcade Fire avoided hubris by remaining vulnerable, rarely more so than on album closer “In the Backseat.” Rather than striking a note of crowd-pleasing uplift, the band opted for ambivalence, framing a quest for self-empowerment within the persistent specter of death.

“My family tree’s / Losing all its leaves,” mourns Regine Chassagne, secondary vocalist and wife of lead singer Win Butler, before boiling a maelstrom of tragedy and tenuous hope into four succinct lines, “Alice died / In the night / I’ve been learning to drive / My whole life.” Meanwhile, the delicate strums of an acoustic guitar are replaced by the insistent thrum of an electric one while a violin expands into an ensemble, throbbing with Chassagne’s heavy heart.

The whole thing sounds like it’s on the verge of shattering at any moment, and it does toward the end, as the strings unspool into a mess of frayed nerves and spilt tears. Then, the curtain is drawn and “Funeral” fades to black, a deeply felt melodrama ending on a whimper.

Butler’s lyrics may often be vague, but his feelings aren’t, as evidenced by the persistent quake in his then-untrained voice. He’s cleaned it up since, but there was something tremendously endearing about his wobbly pitches back then. I’ll forever prefer vocalists who favor emotion and instinct over technical prowess, and it’s songs like “Wake Up” that reinforce my conviction. “Wake Up” is not a song of triumph.

It’s a song of desperation, of bellowing to the heavens because you can’t feel anymore and hoping like hell the same won’t happen to your kids. Yes, it makes for a rousing sing-along, but at its heart, “Wake Up” is the story of a personal crisis in which Butler opens his ragged heart, warbling where his imitators sparkle.

But “Funeral”’s emotional thrust is not limited to Butler and Chassagne’s unguarded vocal performances. Their bandmates play like the world depends on it, conjuring the full spectrum of human emotion. Playing “hard” is a notoriously tricky quality to pinpoint in recorded music, but the sheer ferocity with which Arcade Fire bashes is unmistakable. You can hear both guitar and violin strings straining just a little further than they’re supposed to, drums beating with emphatic persistence. Fittingly, the band creates particularly adept climaxes, tensed joints culminating in cathartic release.

It was the craftsmanship that was lost on so many of Arcade Fire’s followers after “Funeral” was released, which thought all you needed were violins, shout-along choruses and pluck to move the masses. But “Funeral” retains its magic 10 years later, not through stellar songwriting or physical exertion but through a towering ambition communicated through the corridors of the human heart, the secular infused with the spiritual, despair lined with hope. Many have tried to copy the Arcade Fire formula, but the truth is that there is no formula, only a conviction in feelings and the courage to share them. A decade after Arcade Fire offered “Funeral” to the world, that conviction still rings true.

More in Music

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening at Washington University and beyond.

Subscribe