Best Albums of 2022: A Response to Pitchfork

| Managing Chief of Copy
Seven album covers compiled onto a black square.

2022 albums from Animal Collective, Big Thief, Cate Le Bon, Charli XCX, Vince Staples, Wet Leg and Yeule.

Even if I disagree with its critics and dislike the fact that it is an industry institution (blah blah blah), I follow Pitchfork as much as the next guy — probably more than the next guy, if I’m being honest. I’m subscribed to every Pitchfork email newsletter, and I read most of them before sending them to my trash. Last week, I was running an experiment at the lab and had to find some way to waste a four-hour waiting period. Usually, I’ll read through Pitchfork newsletters to kill time, which is where I noticed a new headline: “The 39 Best Albums of 2022 So Far.” I was morbidly curious to find out how much I was going to disagree with the Pitchfork staff. Lo and behold, I was kind of upset by it (everyone has to have the same taste as I do because I have an unhealthy relationship with music, objectively correct opinions and most importantly, a page). While I agree with some of Pitchfork’s picks, I feel like some big hitters were overlooked. Plus, I like making lists.

Beach House: Once Twice Melody

1. Beach House: Once Twice Melody

Best Moment: The swells in “Over and Over,” as the vocals pass the baton to the synths.

Best Song: “ESP,” because it’s the only song I have downloaded on Spotify (why, I couldn’t tell ya).

Recommended If You Like (RIYL): Overachieving, lying on your bed and staring on the ceiling (less-than sober), having a really busy schedule but being “head empty.”



Best Moment: On “crashing down,” when the guitars explode into the track “when it all comes CRASHING DOWN” before fading back out after the chorus.

Best Song: “dont move,” for being the grooviest departure from Arlie’s traditional schtick and having a sick-a– solo.

RIYL: Exceptional indie rock, powerfully catchy choruses, dancing when nobody’s watching.

Harry Styles: Harry’s House

3. Harry Styles: Harry’s House

Best Moment: The very beginning of “Love of My Life,” when I burst into tears as soon as Harry starts singing — it gets me every dang time.

Best Song: “Matilda,” which has the power to steal your attention from whatever you’re doing, especially if the dark lyrics about having a tenuous relationship with your family hit close to home for you. 

RIYL: One Direction, a burning desire to get “lost in the sauce,” nostalgic music (but not the kind of nostalgia everybody else is doing).

Black Country, New Road: Ants From Up There

4. Black Country, New Road: Ants From Up There

Best Moment: The verse on “Bread Song” complaining about someone eating toast in bed and getting crumbs in the sheets. 

Best Song: “Concorde,” for scratching my Bowie itch.

RIYL: Noise, instruments, Black Country, New Road.

Kendrick Lamar: Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers

5. Kendrick Lamar: Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers

Best Moment: Whenever you end up realizing that the album is a therapy session (I knew this was a concept album, but wowza, that’s a new angle).

Best Song: “Father Time,” which is a veritable masterpiece from top to bottom, plus buttery smooth verses from Sampha. 

RIYL: Kendrick, the social awareness that J. Cole claims to have, brown leather.

King Gizzard & The Lizard Wizard: Omnium Gatherum

6. Best Moment: When you start the album, zone out, tune back in and think you’ve heard a few songs only to realize you’re just on the other end of “The Dripping Tap.” 

Best Song: “Kepler-22b,” because I’m a sucker for space motifs in music (see the Arctic Monkeys’ “Tranquility Base”).

RIYL: Genres of music, an eighteen-minute opening track, herpetology.

Oliver Tree: Cowboy Tears

7.  Oliver Tree: Cowboy Tears

Best Moment: Oliver Tree coughing as he describes his smoking on “Cigarettes” (1 to numb the pain, 1 to celebrate, 2 for sex, 3 to sleep, 10 for lunch, and 10 for dinner).

Best Song: “Cowboys Don’t Cry.”

RIYL: Getting slightly angry, Doc Martens with spurs, black F-150s.

Father John Misty: Chloë and the Next 20th Century

8. Father John Misty: Chloë and the Next 20th Century

Best Moment: The guitar solo on “The Next 20th Century” knocks your socks off, thereby freeing the dogs.

Best Song: “Q4”, because it tells the best stand-alone story on the album.

RIYL: Volunteering at retirement homes, American angst, anarchy.

Mitski: Laurel Hell

9. Mitski: Laurel Hell

Best Moment: On “Love Me More,” when your ears get ambushed by the high intensity of the “Maniac” sample.

Best Song: “The Only Heartbreaker,” because — awooga — Mitski’s voice can do little wrong.

RIYL: The Weeknd, that feeling you get when you break up with someone but still kind of miss them (please take me back), painting landscapes.

Mad Tsai: Homecoming

10. Mad Tsai: Homecoming

Best Moment: On “Boy Bi,” when Mad Tsai says “Boy bye” because you get to do the Leo DiCaprio pointing on the couch thing.

Best Song: “Killer Queen” because it’s a catchy pop banger, which is all you need sometimes.

RIYL: Music that is sonically pleasing, your high school era, whatever Spotify means by “Alt Z.”

Sign up for the email edition

Stay up to date with everything happening as Washington University returns to campus.