Whether you love it or hate it, you can’t ignore the spectacle of the musical. From movie classics like Gene Kelly’s “Singin’ in the Rain” to the recent Broadway sensation “Hairspray,” the musical has become an important staple of American theater, drawing both sharp critics and impassioned enthusiasts. The standard American musical employs elaborate sets and costumes which help ease the audience into a suspension of disbelief, where otherwise-normal characters spontaneously break into song whenever there’s a lull in the conversation. But deprive the audience of these visual distractions and you leave them with nothing more than the music, the dialogue, and their own imaginations.
Music and film student Eric Dienstfrey has done just that in his senior project, entitled “She’s Hideous!” The musical, set in 1920’s Vienna, tells the story of the unlikely relationship between a young artist struggling with a “painter’s block” of sorts, and the (presumably) human subject that ultimately wins him the recognition he desperately desires. Far from the classical image of beauty, this artist’s muse appears in the form of an absurdly ugly girl who can’t even manage to step outside without creating a disturbance. This ugliness is completely speculative, however, since the actors have no costumes; the only visual cues the production gives are in the form of dialogue.
Luckily, I had a chance to view a dress rehearsal of the musical before it debuts on April 3rd and was able to speak with its writer/director/pianist after the show.
Cadenza: Why write a musical without any visual elements?
Eric: I’m really attracted to acting through odd obstacles…I like acting through song, I think it’s an interesting way to tell a story…In terms of musical theater, and theater in general, there’s a lot of emphasis on staging, dance, costume design and set design, which is important, but to me the most important thing is the character, and in musical theater, the songs.
C: But even though the musical lacks any kind of visual stimulation, the characters seem to be concerned with the visual.
E: The concept of the show is about a very, very ugly woman, and about not judging her by normal standards, and not judging art by normal standards. I did the show in such a way that you can’t really judge it from how it looks.
C: Did you find having the focus on the sound of the musical over the visual aspect liberating, or was it something that you had to constantly keep in mind?
E: There are definitely certain jokes thrown in there just to take advantage of this, certain lines of dialogue, when they’re singing their stage directions at times, like in the tango when they’re undressing each other to the music and narrating it. That obviously wouldn’t be said if it was shown visually. I wouldn’t say it was liberating; it was sort of a challenge and from that challenge came something.
C: Why did you decide to set the musical in 1920’s Vienna?
E: I think, music-wise, the last real important movement, arguably, was the second Viennese school, with composers like Schoenberg, or Berg, or Weber, and twelve-tone music and later atonal music. I’ve always liked that type of music; there’s something really subtle about a lot of Schoenberg’s piano pieces. And I found it sort of humorous to think: what if Schoenberg were to write a musical?
C: So were you trying to write music that sounded like it came from the second Viennese school?
E: There’s sort of a mixture between Schoenberg-type stuff and 1920’s cabaret-ish music, in terms of the harmonics and certain types of chords and progressions. But I also tried to mix it with another composer that I like from the 70’s, Burt Bacharach.
C: Was the choice of piano and vocals as the only instrumentation out of convenience or did you have something else in mind?
E: I’m sort of a content-over-form person, if a choice has to be made out of convenience, that choice also has to be made out of what you’re doing in the show. In terms of convenience, I didn’t want to worry about getting people to learn the music, orchestrating and whatnot…I had so much else to deal with. So I chose a Schoenberg piece that’s just piano music, and it worked. And also, we’re dealing with the bare essentials of a show. The gimmicks of a brass line or a costume change or whatever, they’re all gimmicks. It’s not really what the content is.
C: Did you find yourself more interested in the music or the dialogue when you were writing this musical?
E: Well, the Schoenberg piece I use is actually six little piano pieces, so I wanted to have six songs in the show, and I had this arch idea of having [the artist’s] solo at the beginning and the end, and [the model’s] solo in between, with two duets in the middle. I’m not really a big fan of dialogue…most of this dialogue gets to the point.
She’s Hideous! will be performed on April 3rd at 7:00 at Steinberg Auditorium. Admission is free.