The theme of this presidency has been war. Whether or not President Bush is responsible for antagonizing the situation is arguable. What is indisputable, however, is that the prospect of war has never been so present in the last 10 years. And we’re not even talking about war with just one country. We’ve already fought a “War on Terrorism” in Afghanistan, we’re about to wage war with Iraq, and we can’t forget about North Korea and Iran, the other two members of the “Axis of Evil.”
The last time we were so embedded in conflict was Vietnam. Back then we had a draft.
Because of the constant threat of war that hangs above us, many in Congress have been debating whether or not to reinstate the draft. As many in the America public so vocally pointed out in the 1960s, a draft is never the answer to war. It is especially not the answer today.
The reason the government used the draft in Vietnam was because the volunteer army lacked the necessary number of soldiers to fight. Not coincidentally, Vietnam was one of the most protested wars in this nation’s history. The public in general was not in support of the conflict. Understandably, in this highly unpopular war, the number of individuals willing to sign up and fight did not meet the military’s need.
Some members of Congress saw this as a problem-and it was. However, their solution to the problem was to force the conscription of thousands of American citizens. What they should have learned from the situation, however, was that Americans were not supporting the war. What better evidence for lack of support could there be other than a shortage of people willing to fight?
Today, with the possibility of war with Iraq and several others, the issue of public support will again become very important. The public, for the most part, supported the President’s decision to bomb Afghanistan. It looks like America will also support a war with Iraq. We cannot say whether the public will continue to support the many future wars that will be necessary if we really intend to “wipe out terrorists.”
What we do know, however, is that if there is enough public support, the issue of a draft will be irrelevant. As long as Americans support a war, people will fight. The fact that not enough people were willing to fight in Vietnam said more about the war than it did about the apathy of the American public. Far from it-the Baby Boomer generation (which fought the Vietnam war) was one of the most activist generations in our history. It is they who lament the apathy of today’s youth. They were active in their refusal to fight, and the government responded by drafting them.
In this day and age, America no longer fights domestic wars. While a war on terrorism could be construed as a domestic war, the reality is that the vast majority of conflicts that this country has faced over the last 150 years have been foreign. The fact that the public may be hesitant to fight a foreign war is a good thing; it means we are thinking of people other than ourselves. The government should not stifle this exercise in free thinking by drafting a public that does not want to fight.
During Vietnam, many activists went so far as to defy the draft; they claimed student deferments, burned their draft cards, or fled to Canada. Instead of being moved by these demonstrations against forced participation in war, the government responded by eliminating student deferments and working out an extradition treaty with Canada. Today, a college student may defer service for only one semester before he is interrupted from his studies to fight.
Conscientious objectors may find themselves employed in some other aspect of military service, such as filling posts on domestic bases that have been vacated by fighting soldiers. By doing so, however, the government is still forcing citizens to work on a war effort that they themselves do not support.
The fundamental right not to support a war is what a draft eliminates. The government should not have the right to force you to participate in a war effort. Voters should not have the right to vote you into active service. If you support a war, then go fight. Don’t make us do it.