College Media Network

Water bottle initiative important step forward

Staff Editorial

Print this article

Published: Friday, November 21, 2008

Updated: Friday, November 21, 2008

Next semester the University will no longer sell bottled water on campus. This decision is part of a series of green initiatives set to be implemented by the University, but it is the first to have a direct impact on students. Many students are bristling at the idea of the University forcing them to go green or are anticipating the inconvenience and aggravation of a world (or campus) without water bottles. But once students see beyond their annoyance, they might realize that this step toward ‘green’ is a step in the right direction both for the University and its students.

In the face of real and serious environmental problems, the nation will have to make sacrifices in order to ensure a better future. There may come a time when Americans will be forced to use less power, drive less or conserve water. In comparison to these possible (and likely) scenarios, Washington University students’ loss of bottled water isn’t that great of a sacrifice. In fact, it’s a rather small gesture that should be followed by more rigorous green initiatives campus-wide. Washington University should work hard to urge students to conserve power and water. It should additionally seek moderation in its own use of lighting, heating and cooling. Does every light on campus have to be on all the time? And do the classrooms need to be so icy cold in the summer? Or so warm and toasty in the winter? Small changes can have a big impact; it is time for the University to be far more aggressive about going green.

It is also time for students to employ a viewpoint shift. Losing our disposable water bottles could be a good thing. Not only are disposable water bottles harmful to the environment—they are yet another example of unnecessary plastic packaging, and they consume energy and create waste in each step of their ‘life’ cycle (manufacturing, transportation, and recycling)—but they make an impact on your wallet as well.

A liter of water at the Village mart sells for $2.59. If you were to buy one a day for a month you’d be paying about $80. For an entire school year you’re looking at roughly $600. For water! If you buy a Nalgene and fill it with free water every day (St. Louis has some of the highest quality tap water in the country), think about how much money you’ll save. Not only are you protecting the planet, but you’re being economical as well. And isn’t that what being a college student is all about?

Comments

6 comments
Laughing at you
Sun Nov 23 2008 01:19
People fighting for the elimination of bottled water need to wake up. People will simply take MORE plastic cups from Whispers. Instead of being able to use a bottle the entire day, will go through more plastic than before. Think about it. This SHOULD be about education, not elimination. And Nalgene's do taste funny, I agree with Alumni. This is the silliest ban I've ever heard of... let's ban pop before we ban water bottles. We do have soda fountains all over campus, you know. Thank you for contributing to the obesity of America.
'01 Alum
Sat Nov 22 2008 13:26
I can't believe there's even a debate about this. If you're worried about the "cleanliness" that can only be found in bottled water, you need to do a little more research. Bottled water comes from springs/ lakes/ reservoirs that are OUTSIDE and not subject to the more stringent testing and regulatory levels for certain contaminants. Some bottled waters, in fact, are simply tap water that has been purified (Aquafina and Dasani are two that come to mind). Buy a Brita or Pur water filter for your tap or pitcher for your refrigerator- you'll have great tasting water wherever you go. (Trust me- I lived in DC for years and it even made the water there bearable). As far as Nalgene bottles causing strange tastes, I have to laugh at that. I've never found that but if you have, you should be aware that manufacturers have started using different materials in their bottles to eliminate controversial components that were recently brought to light. You can also buy other brands that do have removable tops that are dishwasher safe or specific cleaning tablets designed to sanitize bottles- with plain old warm water- when necessary (Nalgene itself, in fact, manufacturers a package of about 20 tablets that sells for about $5.) Please stop with the excuses and get used to the times- disposable plastic bottles of water are neither healthier for you or the environment. I would hope most Wash U. students are embracing the opportunity to do something good for themselves and the environment as a whole rather than complain about inconsequential "inconveniences" with little basis in fact. This is one decision I am proud of the administration for making and seriously hope today's students are as aware of the world around them as they were just 7 years ago because if not there is something seriously wrong with the current student body. Please prove me wrong and embrace the change rather than complain about it. I'm off my soapbox now and about to drink from my Nalgene bottle as soon as I submit this. :)
Vidya
Sat Nov 22 2008 02:25
If you get sick when you use a Nalgene, it's because you're not cleaning it properly. It needs to be emptied, rinsed, and let out to dry every day, and washed thoroughly several times a week. However, if you're concerned about the plastic (which has long-term health implications as well as the harm of emitting VOCs into your environment and body, affecting both your physiology and psychology), Whole Foods sells stainless steel water bottles that don't have the same taste/health concerns. Personally, I carry around a glass jar with a screw-on lid. No problems there. Is bottled water really the best solution you can think of? And it's completely feasible to get around a campus with NO water bottle - there are fountains everywhere. Dining halls all have water available for your drinking pleasure.

Further, there are places in this world where potable water is not a reality. Having good, clean, unlimited, free water is such a blessing. (There's no such thing as a free lunch, so remember that your tax dollars PAY for this unlimited resource.) Do we need to wait until drought becomes a looming threat right here to start caring about water conservation, or can we learn from the drought that has been plaguing other parts of this country and this world? To SHIP water from one place to another that has perfectly good tap water is simply criminal. How much more unsustainable can you get? The mental reassurance you derive from drinking bottled water as a result of misinformation or confusion or ignorance hardly justifies the exorbitant consumption of resources and energy in bringing you that bottle of water.
If you still have a problem with the abolition of bottled water on campus, email me at vksantosh@wustl.edu and I will do my best to explain the seriousness of the crime and help you to come up with a way to hydrate yourself satisfactorily without it.

Alumni
Fri Nov 21 2008 18:12
I agree with the other comment. I drink bottled water because I believe that it's healthier than soda or flavored water. Also, I have tried on several occasions to use Nalgene bottles, and although St. Louis water is of high quality (I never had a problem drinking out of campus drinking fountains), the water eventually does taste strange because of the bottle. Students on campus are not able put their bottles in the dishwasher or thoroughly clean them in bathroom sinks. I also have noticed that each time I decide to be green and use a Nalgene, I end up sick. It may be a conicidence, but I believe that bottled water is necessary for sanitary purposes.
Alumni
Fri Nov 21 2008 16:23
I agree with the other comment. I drink bottled water because I believe that it's healthier than soda or flavored water. Also, I have tried on several occasions to use Nalgene bottles, and although St. Louis water is of high quality (I never had a problem drinking out of campus drinking fountains), the water eventually does taste strange because of the bottle. Students on campus are not able put their bottles in the dishwasher or thoroughly clean them in bathroom sinks. I also have noticed that each time I decide to be green and use a Nalgene, I end up sick. It may be a conicidence, but I believe that bottled water is necessary for sanitary purposes.




Verify you are human: