Pretending to be President Obama?
Jeff Nelson’s unstated campaign to become the Wash. U. version of President Barack Obama is off to a great start.
His recent campus address was a wealth of presidential parallels. Not only was it named the “Campus State of the Union,” its post on the Student Union Web site actually included a picture of the real State of the Union. Even better, Nelson’s speech itself contained many lines reminiscent of Obama’s trademark oratory.
Consider Nelson’s opening assessment that despite the weak economy, “the state of our student body is strong—stronger than at any other point during my time at Wash. U.” In his own state of the union address, President Obama delivered a comparable opening, declaring that out of the ruin of the economic downturn, “the United States of America will emerge stronger than before.”
Nelson continued the presidential rhetoric with his plea that “we continue to stand unified,” his reference to his “ambitious agenda” and his promise to make this “the most open, transparent and accessible administration in recent Student Union history.” If Nelson just eliminates the words “Student Union,” he can probably recycle those phrases for later use on the floor of the U.S. House.
If only Nelson had his own Shepard Fairy portrait and Portuguese water dog. Oh, and if only he was talking about health care and economic policy instead of school calendar improvements and the problem of over-programming.
It is true that Nelson did not ever quote Obama in his speech or even make gratuitous references to hope and change. Nevertheless, he was certainly trying to act as presidential as is possible for someone discussing parochial concerns like campus food.
Yet I can hardly fault Nelson for engaging in a crime of which I too am guilty. In fact, I suspect all Wash. U. students are at least slightly complicit. As college students, we are all engaged in our own moments of playacting.
We playact as fully trained doctors by joining EST. We mimic real teachers by tutoring elementary school students in the afternoons. Nelson imitates our country’s president, and I pretend to be an op-ed columnist with real influence and readership.
Our theatrical pursuits are not harmful or even futile; on the contrary, these invented roles often have real-world value. EST provides an incredibly useful medical service for Wash. U. students. Tutoring helps struggling students succeed. Nelson plays a truly important role in improving our undergraduate experience. As for me, well, at least my parents like my columns.
But I think that the true value of these pursuits often lies in the future. Our playacting is primarily a way of training for our roles in the real world. EST members grow up to be doctors, tutors become teachers, and Jeff Nelson will eventually run for president. I’d add that I might grow up to be a real columnist, but given the state of journalism, I think I’m more likely to end up living in a cardboard box and using newspapers as heating fuel.
I often wonder whether the time and effort we spend on campus concerns might be better spent on problems affecting the real world. I think that even as college students, we have a great deal to offer to the broader community. Yet perhaps the world is often better served by our playacting.
Without years of medical training, EST members are not qualified to serve as doctors. College-age tutors are often not quite ready to command a classroom. Jeff Nelson has a few more years before he’ll meet the constitutional qualifications needed to run for president. And while I don’t think there are a lot of specific requirements for becoming a professional columnist, the fact remains that The New York Times will not soon hire me.
So I cannot condemn Nelson for his charade. After all, his chances of becoming president are probably better than my journalistic job prospects.
Besides, college should be our time to practice, to pretend to be useful and important, in the hope that one day we actually will be. If we are lucky, we can accomplish some good along the way. Mostly, however, we can enjoy our small stage while it lasts and prepare for our real debut.

Where did all of the other comments on this article go??
This article is absurd… I don’t really think I need to point this out but I guess I will anyway. Of course tutors aren’t teachers, they are TUTORS, they are not equal, one is not the undeveloped version of the other. Same goes for EST- we have EMTs both at WashU and employed by our home towns and cities because they perform a job that doctors don’t. As for the comparison to Obama, is this an attack or what is it? Envy? What is your point? Is it because they are both people of color? Why didn’t you compare him to Clinton or Reagan or JFK? All presidents use rhetoric.
Come to think of it this article disgusts me.
J.O.S.E.
That’s quite a feat — having written the most confusing, obnoxious, and superfluous article on the Studlife website. Congratulations, Eve. I concur in your own assessment that you don’t have a future in journalism.
This article is the most confusing thing I’ve read on here in months. The tone is a bizarre mix that’s part sarcastic mockery, self-deprecating humor that is way too repetitive, and even after reading it twice I’m left with “and your point is…..”
you should read the response here:
http://www.studlife.com/forum/2009/09/18/no-need-to-pretend/
wait…so Jeff was trying to be Obama even though he didn’t quote or reference him once? Or no, I get it, your concern is that he’s acting arbitrarily “Presidential”…are the leaders of a student government not supposed to lead? Jeff is constitutionally required to present a state of the student union twice a year, and just as every state governor (note: ALL of them) that present a “state of the state” aren’t doing it in worship of President Obama, so do I have trouble reading anything into this but mean-spirited mockery…not to mention every bit of rhetoric you cite has been used by every president in my short life, from Clinton to Bush now to Obama…where are you seeing this Obama comparison, is it perhaps because you see the black guy acting like a president? Because truly, after that the comparison totally dies, considering he’s acting exactly like the leader of a student GOVERNMENT is supposed to act…
I’m not sure I understand the tone of this article. Are you mocking Jeff Nelson? Are you not aware of the things he does that goes PAST overprogramming and campus food (which is AMAZING, btw). I wonder what you are doing to change the world. As you stated, you too are just a pretender, and you’re really not all that good at it. At least there are some people who are out there being ACTIVE members of the WashU community, while others are just all…TALK.