Cadenza predicts the Emmys
Cadenza knows what you’re thinking. Last year’s Emmy Awards ceremony was boring and painful to watch. The choice to have five reality-show hosts emcee was arguably one of the worst ideas ever, and it ruined the integrity and fun of the entire event. But this year they have completely redeemed themselves with the selection of the wondrous Neil Patrick Harris as host. He is sure to be as adorable and hilarious as always, and who knows? Maybe there will be a musical number! (“Glee” fans, did we convince you?) Furthermore, in recent years, television has become a medium that more than rivals film in its ability to continually create and develop complex story arcs. In other words, television—the good kind, at least—can be serious, brilliant, funny and, most importantly, culturally significant. In honor of this event, Cadenza has compiled a list of the most important categories and expounded on which nominees should win and which actually will take home the award. Tune in to CBS at 7 p.m. (CT) on Sunday to see if we’re right! – H.S.
Outstanding Drama Series
The Nominees:
‘Big Love’ | HBO
‘Breaking Bad’ | AMC
‘Damages’ | FX Networks
‘Dexter’ | Showtime
‘House’ | FOX
‘Lost’ | ABC
‘Mad Men’ | AMC
Should win: ‘Lost’
Can we give “Lost” some love, please? The show has been nominated numerous times but has not won the Outstanding Drama Series category since 2005, and the writers and creators deserve the award for the direction in which they have taken the show since then. Last season’s ingenious time-hopping brought “Lost” to a new science-fiction realm and opened up a world of possibilities in a way that seemed almost plausible. Sheer brilliance. As they enter the final season, everyone involved deserves some recognition.
Will win: ‘Mad Men’
Along with everyone else on the planet, “Mad Men” is one of my favorite shows, and the second season was absolutely phenomenal. They really hit their stride and made every episode even darker, smarter and funnier than the last. Plus, Peggy’s haircut truly revolutionized her character—and I’m only half-kidding. But they swept the ceremony just last year, and I just can’t get over the fact that there’s an episode in the new season that features blackface. Just for that, “Lost” all the way! – H.S.
Outstanding Comedy Series

Jack McBrayer as Kenneth Parcell and Alec Baldwin as Jack Donaghy in 30 Rock (Jessica Miglio | NBC Photo)
The Nominees:
‘Entourage’ | HBO
‘Weeds’ | Showtime
‘How I Met Your Mother’ | CBS
‘Flight of the Conchords’ | HBO
‘30 Rock’ | NBC
‘The Office’ | NBC
‘Family Guy’ | FOX
Should win: ‘30 Rock’
The sharpest half hour on television didn’t lose a step in its third season. That’s a good thing because comedies tend to hit their peak in their second seasons. “30 Rock” has the right stuff and cast to keep the good times coming.
Will win: ‘30 Rock’
This would make it a three-peat. Maybe they should rename the category, “Best Show That Isn’t ‘30 Rock.’” Give the other shows a chance, you know? – P.O.
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series

Hugh Laurie as Dr. Gregory House in the sixth season of House. (Florian Schneider | FOX)
The Nominees:
‘House’: Hugh Laurie as Dr. Gregory House
‘Dexter’: Michael C. Hall as Dexter Morgan
‘The Mentalist’: Simon Baker as Patrick Jane
‘In Treatment’: Gabriel Byrne as Paul
‘Breaking Bad’: Bryan Cranston as Walter White
‘Mad Men’: Jon Hamm as Don Draper
Should win: Hugh Laurie as Dr. Gregory House
Who doesn’t love a good scoundrel, especially one as endearing as House? Thus, I can’t help but want Hugh Laurie to win. Wouldn’t mind hearing one of his hilarious acceptance speeches too.
Will win: Jon Hamm as Don Draper
But I expect Jon Hamm to pick up the trophy, after being robbed last year. – C.W.
Outstanding Lead Actor in a Comedy Series
The Nominees:
‘The Office’: Steve Carell as Michael Scott
‘Monk’: Tony Shalhoub as Adrian Monk
‘Flight of the Conchords’: Jemaine Clement as Jemaine
‘The Big Bang Theory’: Jim Parsons as Sheldon Cooper
‘30 Rock’: Alec Baldwin as Jack Donaghy
‘Two and a Half Men’: Charlie Sheen as Charlie Harper
Should win: Alec Baldwin as Jack Donaghy
Alec Baldwin brought his A-game this season (then again, when doesn’t he?). Heck, he should get five Emmys for absolutely owning Generalissimo. NBC, I demand a spin-off, pronto!
Will win: Steve Carell as Michael Scott
Can you believe that Steve Carell has never won an Emmy before? C’mon, that can’t last. – P.O.
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Drama Series
The Nominees:
‘The Closer’: Kyra Sedgwick as Brenda Leigh Johnson
‘Brothers & Sisters’: Sally Field as Nora Walker
‘Saving Grace’: Holly Hunter as Grace Hanadarko
‘Damages’: Glenn Close as Patty Hewes
‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’: Mariska Hargitay as Detective Olivia Benson
‘Mad Men’: Elisabeth Moss as Peggy Olson
Should win: Elisabeth Moss as Peggy Olson
This first-time nominee acts with a wholesome modesty, ensuring empathy for her character.
Will win: Glenn Close as Patty Hewes
Glenn Close has it in the bag to win for a second year in a row. –C.W.
Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series
The Nominees:
‘The Sarah Silverman Program’: Sarah Silverman as Sarah Silverman
‘Weeds’: Mary-Louise Parker as Nancy Botwin
‘The New Adventures of Old Christine’: Julia Louis-Dreyfus as Christine
‘United States of Tara’: Toni Collette as Tara Gregson
‘Samantha Who?’: Christina Applegate as Samantha Newly
‘30 Rock’: Tina Fey as Liz Lemon
Should Win: Toni Collette as Tara Gregson
Comedic legend Jerry Lewis once said, “I don’t like any female comedians.” No narrow-minded person today can dispute how talented and utterly hilarious the six women nominated for outstanding actress in a comedy series. While all the other nominees in this category only portray one character, Toni Collette deserves the Emmy as she balances the act of playing four. On “The United States of Tara,” Collette plays a woman with dissociative identity disorder, who is unable to control herself as she transitions between three other ‘alters.’ These other personas range from retro housewife Alice to sexually ravenous teenager T to vulgar Vietnam vet Buck. The question is whether Collette should be nominated in a comedy or drama category. (I personally believe she should be nominated in both.) Collette’s enormous talent is displayed as she seamlessly slips from character to character. She can play an unruly teenage girl who makes out with her own son’s boyfriend and then morphs into June Cleaver with one wink with more conviction than most actresses could. Her performance on this dark, twisted, black comedy is heartbreaking, inspiring and always fresh. Though it’s unlikely she will win her first nomination as Tara, Collette should win for her exemplary job as a working mother who desperately tries to hold her family together as her own life falls apart.
Will Win: Tina Fey as Liz Lemon
Tina Fey is definitely the one to beat at this year’s awards. Aside from taking home the Emmy last year in this category, “30 Rock,” which she also created, is nominated for a record of 22 Emmy awards. With a great ensemble cast that features fellow Emmy nominees this year Alec Baldwin, Jane Krakowski, Tracy Morgan and Jack McBrayer, Fey shines out as the loveable boss Liz Lemon who holds the fictional show, “TGS” together. Fey’s wit and charm come across easily, as she writes most of the material on the show. The biggest threat to Fey’s potential win comes from Mary-Louise Parker, who has been nominated the last two years for her role as Nancy Botwin on “Weeds.” Despite Parker, Tina Fey is a sure bet. – A.J.
Outstanding Supporting Actor in a Comedy Series
Nominees:
‘Entourage’: Kevin Dillon as Johnny Drama
‘Two and a Half Man’: Jon Cryer as Alan Harper
‘How I Met Your Mother’: Neil Patrick Harris as Barney Stinson
‘30 Rock’: Tracy Morgan as Tracy Jordan
‘30 Rock’: Jack McBrayer as Kenneth Parcell
‘The Office’: Rainn Wilson as Dwight Schrute
Should win: Jack McBrayer as Kennet Parcell
As a “30 Rock” fan, this category is a tough one to pick. Choosing between the bumbling Jack McBrayer and the clueless Tracy Morgan is almost impossible as both of them help to make the show what it is. In the end, though, Jack McBrayer – who is funnier, quirkier, more original, and more entertaining – should win Supporting Actor.
Will win: Neil Patrick Harris as Barney Stinson
It’s really down to Rainn Wilson (“The Office”) and Neil Patrick Harris (“How I Met Your Mother”) in this category. While “The Office” has more Emmy pull in general, I think that Harris will ultimately take this one. Aside from being a hilarious actor, he’s on a roll with awards shows, successfully hosting the Tonys and now hosting the Emmys. He has the upper hand. – A.T.
Outstanding Supporting Actress in a Comedy Series
Nominees
‘Pushing Daisies’: Kristin Chenoweth as Olive Snook
‘30 Rock’: Jane Krakowski as Jenna Maroney
‘Weeds’: Elizabeth Perkins as Celia Hodes
‘Ugly Betty’: Vanessa Williams as Wilhelmina Slater
‘Saturday Night Live’: Amy Poehler as Various Characters
‘Saturday Night Live’: Kristen Wiig as Various Characters
Should Win: Kristen Chenoweth as Olive Snook
Kristen Chenoweth (“Pushing Daisies”) should win, hands down. As Olive Snook, Chenoweth brings an extra level quirkiness to an already quirky show. She’s crazy and neurotic, and Kristen makes it work.
Will Win: Amy Poehler
I really don’t think that there is much of a competition here. Amy Poehler shined this past season of “SNL” as the funniest regular cast member. Her Hillary Clinton impersonations and Weekend Updates were some of the highlights of the show (aside from Tina Fey as Sarah Palin, of course). None of the other nominees have anywhere near as much momentum. – A.T.
Outstanding Supporting Actor In A Drama Series
Nominees
‘Boston Legal’: William Shatner as Denny Crane
‘Lost’: Michael Emerson as Ben Linus
‘Damages’: William Hurt as Daniel Purcell
‘Boston Legal’: Christian Clemenson as Jerry Espenson
‘Breaking Bad’: Aaron Paul as Jesse Pinkman
‘Mad Men’: John Slattery as Roger Sterling
Should/Will Win: Michael Emerson as Ben Linus
Michael Emerson should and will win. No one else in this category has a character as complex or creepy as his. Think his third nomination will be a charm! – C.W.
Outstanding Supporting Actress In A Drama Series
Nominees:
‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Sandra Oh as Dr. Cristina Yang
‘Damages’: Rose Byrne as Ellen Parsons
‘Grey’s Anatomy’: Chandra Wilson as Dr. Miranda Bailey
‘In Treatment’: Dianne West as Gina
‘In Treatment’: Hope Davis as Mia
‘24’: Cherry Jones as President Allison Taylor
Should Win: Sandra Oh as Dr. Cristina Yang
I would love to see Sandra Oh win after being nominated for her role as Cristina in Grey’s Anatomy for the past five years.
Will Win: Dianne West as Gina
But think Dianne Wiest has it for a second year in a row. – C.W.
Outstanding Commercial
The Nominees:
‘Airport Lounge’: Amex/Platinum Card
‘Alec in Huluwood’: Hulu
‘Bottled Courage’: Nike
‘Circus’: Anheuser-Busch Budweiser
‘Heist’: Coca-Cola
‘Magazine Buyer’: Anheuser-Busch Bud Light
‘Tips’: Career Builder
‘Wedding’: Sprint Nextel
Should win: ‘Bottled Courage’ – Nike
This commercial has it all: amazing sports clips thrown at you in fast motion, inspiring messages (“Everything You Need is Already Inside”), and the background music of The Killers’ best song: “All These Things That I’ve Done.” Besides, any commercial that makes me want to get out there and play sports has truly accomplished something. I’ve got soul, indeed. – H.S.
Will Win: Alec in Huluwod – Hulu
It stars Alec Baldwin. If that weren’t enough, he pokes fun at television, corporations, the mass public and even aliens! The cynicism of the tagline (“Hulu: An evil plot to destroy the world. Enjoy.”) will most likely win out over the simple, optimistic joy of the Nike commercial. –H.S.
Outstanding Guest Actor In A Comedy Series
The Nominees:
‘Desperate Housewives’: Beau Bridges as Eli Scruggs
‘Saturday Night Live’ • Host: Justin Timberlake : Justin Timberlake as Various Characters
’30 Rock’: Steve Martin as Gavin Volure
’30 Rock’: Jon Hamm as Dr. Drew Baird
’30 Rock’: Alan Alda as Milton Greene
Should Win: Justin Timberlake on SNL
Can someone just make the man a regular cast member? He brings joy and energy to every sketch, saving the not-so-funny ones—and, let’s face it, that’s most of them—with sly jabs at himself and everyone else, including Britney Spears. Even as Lorne Michaels fires and hires, Timberlake keeps coming back and winning every time, and that says something.
Will Win: Jon Hamm on 30 Rock
Jon Hamm is the dreamiest man of this millenium, and he uses it to his advantage with good humor. He also just happens to be a fantastic actor, and his appearance on 30 Rock was solidly funny. However, when it went down the whole his-sister-is-actually-his-mom path, Hamm’s talents were a bit wasted on a silly plotline. Plus, he has won, like, a billion awards for “Mad Men.” Give JT some love, Emmys! – H.S.
Outstanding Guest Actress In A Comedy Series
The Nominees:
‘The Big Bang Theory’: Christine Baranski as Beverly Hofstadter
‘Monk’: Gena Rowlands as Marge
‘My Name Is Earl’: Betty White as Crazy Witch Lady
‘Saturday Night Live’: Tina Fey as Governor Sarah Palin (Spoof)
’30 Rock’: Jennifer Aniston as Claire
’30 Rock’: Elaine Stritch as Colleen Donaghy
Should Win: Tina Fey as Sarah Palin
It’s just pure luck that Fey happens to have an uncanny resemblance to the ex-Governor, but it took Fey’s impeccable comic timing and fearlessness to make the sketch a national sensation. She actually made the opening SNL sketch funny, and that is a feat within itself.
Will Win: Tina Fey as Sarah Palin
It’s likely that more people watched Fey pretend to be Palin than footage of Palin herself, therefore linking the sketch directly to the campaign and its outcome. If that’s not influential, I don’t know what is. –H.S.
Outstanding Host For A Reality Or Reality-Competition Program
The Nominees:
‘The Amazing Race’: Phil Keoghan, Host
‘American Idol’: Ryan Seacrest, Host
‘Dancing With The Stars’: Tom Bergeron, Host
‘Project Runway’: Heidi Klum, Host
‘Survivor’: Jeff Probst, Host
‘Top Chef’:Padma Lakshmi, Host, Tom Colicchio, Co-Host
Should Win: Phil Keoghan from The Amazing Race
Phil is the perfect reality show host: like a loving parent, he cares about the contestants, but also knows when to put them in their place. He’s only involved when he needs to be, and he’s from New Zealand. Done and done.
Will Win: Phil Keoghan from The Amazing Race
Phil will win, hands down. What really needs to be said for this category is how undeserving Tom Bergeron is to be nominated for ANY category. Undoubtedly the least funny person on the face of the earth, he has wrangled not one but TWO jobs hosting television programs. Seriously? I’d much rather watch Daisy Fuentes and that other dude host “America’s Funniest Home Videos” than ever see or hear from Tom Bergeron again. –H.S.

hahahaha tom bergeron